Wednesday, May 19, 2010

Bullseye: Attitudes Towards Laity

Paul Borden makes so many absolutely flabbergasting statements about how lay members ought to be “dealt with” that it is hard to know where to start this subject. His statements stem from the previously discussed position that the congregation is the primary unit of mission and therefore sacrificing individuals is acceptable if you believe that doing so will benefit the congregation. Beyond the arguments we have already advanced in opposition to that position, the reality is that individuals can survive without the congregation if they need to, but congregations cannot continue to exist without individuals. Therefore, we go into this particular analysis with the assumption that we don’t need to reestablish that there is no such thing as an expendable soul. With that in mind, let’s look at some of Borden’s statements.

“One reason we are often unwilling to create specific goals and measures of effectiveness is that we know that many in our 'family' will not measure up. Yet if we are committed to mission we must tell such people that if they cannot change they can no longer have positions in leadership. Such actions go against our current value of family. We say these people are part of the family so we cannot embarrass them or hurt them. As a result, we let our institutions develop a codependent habit of protection, thereby avoiding missional goals that demand accountability” (p.24).

“We are also willing to confront those congregations and congregational leaders (the emotional terrorists) who for years have chewed up pastors and spit them out” (p.32).

We can’t speak to the sort of family life Borden has experienced, but this doesn’t sound like a description of our families. Our understanding of family life includes calling family members on bad or unhealthful behaviors, or when they are not performing in a way that best utilizes their potential. The key is that this is done in love, because the family desires the best good for the member they are addressing. This behavior is a necessary part of maintaining a healthy family. There may be families who refuse to address the unhealthy behaviors of its members, just as there may be organizations who refuse to address unhealthy behaviors of their members, and as a result allow the entire unit to become unhealthy. But the bottom line here is not the legitimacy of the metaphor of a family being applied to the church (which was initiated by Christ Himself), but rather whether the relationships in that church family are healthy or unhealthy. If those relationships are so unhealthy that it is not possible to address issues with members in love and a desire for their best good, then addressing them without love and in a spirit that assumes they are disposable is certainly only going to make matters worse. “Do not rebuke an older man harshly, but exhort him as if he were your father. Treat younger men as brothers, older women as mothers, and younger women as sisters, with absolute purity” (1 Tim. 5:1, 2).

“One thing we who were new to the region had learned in former ministries was that even good changes are resisted by those who hold current positions of influence, if that change means they no longer have influence. We had also learned that most who were in positions of influence now would resist change, again, no matter how effective that change might be, since those changes would be perceived as a repudiation of their current leadership, which in most cases was true” (p.134).

We are struck by the contrast between this statement and the statements discussed in the previous chapter of this series in which Borden claims, “I always assume the best…of every pastor” (p.110), and speaks of the “moral obligation” (p.42) to train pastors in the skills necessary to accomplish the tasks they are given. As we said in the previous chapter, we believe that the principle of believing the best of someone until proven otherwise should be applied to both pastors and lay members. Here Borden openly confesses that he starts by assuming the worst of lay members. It then ceases to be surprising that he can so easily implement such ruthless actions against them.

But let’s get back to that moral obligation. If pastors, who have formal theological and ministerial training, could be in need of additional training in order to be effective, doesn’t it stand to reason that the same could be true of lay members? Borden speaks of repudiating the current lay leadership. If they are fulfilling their obligations to the best of their training it hardly seems fair that they should be repudiated for failing to use skills they haven’t been trained to develop. Lay leaders should be given as much opportunity and assistance to develop their ministry potential as pastors are given. We are willing to allow that such lay leaders might be filling positions for which their spiritual gifts are not best suited, but in that case the moral obligation becomes one of helping the individual find the area of ministry in which they are most effective, rather than simply plowing them out of the way of the new order of things. Every individual has a work to do for God.

“Our heavenly Father has been pleased to make men co-laborers with himself in the work of human redemption. Those who have been commissioned to preach the gospel are not the only ones whom he will use as his instruments. All whose minds have been illuminated by the Holy Spirit will in their turn be required to enlighten others. 'None of us liveth to himself.' Every individual has his station of duty in the accomplishment of God's great plan. And every one who receives and obeys the light which God has given, will be a living witness for Christ and the truth” (Review and Herald, February 9, 1886 par. 4).

“Not all are called to engage in the same line of labor, but to every man and woman who enters the service of Christ, are given responsibilities to bear, and a special work to do. My brethren and sisters, Christ sends you this message, 'Search the Scriptures; for in them ye think ye have eternal life; and they are they which testify of Me.' Humble your hearts before God, and seek counsel of Him who never makes a mistake. …You are Christ's purchased possession. Ask Him to tell you what He would have you do” (Jehovah Is Our King, p.5).

“Our churches are not receiving the kind of training that will lead them to walk in all humility of mind, to put away all pride of external display, and to labor for the inward adorning. The efficiency of the church is precisely what the zeal, purity, self-denial, and intelligent labor of the ministers make it. An active missionary spirit should characterize its individual members. They must have deeper piety, stronger faith, and broader views. They must make more thorough work in personal effort. What we need is a living religion. A single individual of enlarged conceptions of duty, whose soul is in communion with God and who is full of zeal for Christ, will exert a powerful influence for good. He drinks at no low, turbid, polluted stream, but from the pure, high waters at the fountainhead; and he can communicate a new spirit and power to the church. As the pressure from without increases, God would have His church vitalized by the sacred, solemn truths they believe. The Holy Spirit from heaven, working with the sons and daughters of God, will surmount obstacles and hold the vantage ground against the enemy. God has great victories in reserve for His truth-loving, commandment-keeping people. The fields are already whitening for the harvest. We have light, and rich, glorious endowments from heaven in the truth made ready to our hands; but men and women have not been educated and disciplined to work in the fast-ripening harvest fields” (Testimonies to the Church, Vol. 5, pp.581, 582).

Borden’s beliefs about lay members are self-fulfilling. He assumes that his strategies will be opposed, and then admits that he deliberately goes about stirring up opposition.

“The best way to expose poor values and give congregations the opportunity to embrace new values is to create stress. Therefore, in our prescription process we usually offered some ways to put the body under stress” (p.94).

Having made the problem, Borden goes about “fixing” it.

“We were open to confronting individuals who were unable to make the changes or who even worked against the changes” (p.63).

“For example we would often have people take on new behaviors and responsibilities and then act as though no change had occurred. In many cases it was simply a habitual response from the past while in others it was done in anger or malice. Every such case needed a response that was appropriate to the situation” (p.112).

“Third, we wanted the pastor to help us understand what we would encounter during the consultation weekend and who would be the most resistant to change and why that was so. Fourth, we wanted to know how we could help the pastor deal with those people most resistant to change” (p.88).

“When congregations are in decline or on a plateau those controlling it need to be replaced with those who will lead it to grow. Such action often creates friction. When this friction occurs it is important for those with influence to use it to protect the new leaders from the former leaders who would often rather be in positions of influence than see health and growth occur” (p.97).

This brings us to the subject of motive. Borden assumes that the exclusive motivation for opposition to his philosophies and systems is protection of personal power, status, and control. While Borden may be right in some cases (and we will address that eventuality in a moment), we find ourselves compelled to point out that there is another possibility—sincere conviction that his philosophies and systems are wrong. When this is the motive the solution is to have an open and honest dialogue. Such dialogue might not always produce agreement, but it would go a long way in reducing the friction and general angst of the situation. The key words here are “open” and “honest.” If either side enters the room with their minds made up the exercise is useless. The openness also encompasses making these dialogues accessible and transparent to the entire congregation. Trying to be secretive about and/or impose limitations on the communication will only exacerbate the friction.

The thing of it is, Borden doesn’t do dialogue. His approach goes into a situation assuming that it knows what is right and has all the answers and needs only for the parties concerned to either jump on the bandwagon or get out of the way. When placed face to face with such a disinterested juggernaut the only option available to those with serious concerns is to “raise a stink.” Some would say that there is also the option of completely keeping silent, but both the Bible and the Spirit of Prophesy condemn those who keep silent when they ought to speak up for God.

“He sent back this answer: ‘Do not think that because you are in the king's house you alone of all the Jews will escape. For if you remain silent at this time, relief and deliverance for the Jews will arise from another place, but you and your father's family will perish. And who knows but that you have come to royal position for such a time as this?’” (Esther 4:13, 14).

“Now as in former ages, the presentation of a truth that reproves the sins and errors of the times will excite opposition. 'Everyone that doeth evil hateth the light, neither cometh to the light, lest his deeds should be reproved.' John 3:20. As men see that they cannot maintain their position by the Scriptures, many determine to maintain it at all hazards, and with a malicious spirit they assail the character and motives of those who stand in defense of unpopular truth…

“In view of this, what is the duty of the messenger of truth? Shall he conclude that the truth ought not to be presented, since often its only effect is to arouse men to evade or resist its claims? No; he has no more reason for withholding the testimony of God's word, because it excites opposition, than had earlier Reformers. …They received grace and truth, not for themselves alone, but that, through them, the knowledge of God might enlighten the earth. Has God given light to His servants in this generation? Then they should let it shine forth to the world”
(The Great Controversy, pp. 458, 459).

“Those who have too little courage to reprove wrong, or who through indolence or lack of interest make no earnest effort to purify the family or the church of God, are held accountable for the evil that may result from their neglect of duty. We are just as responsible for evils that we might have checked in others by exercise of parental or pastoral authority as if the acts had been our own” (Patriarchs and Prophets, p.578).

Of course, there is always the possibility that the motives of the objectors are not altruistic. Even then, however, we don’t endorse Borden’s methods of addressing the situation.

"Congregational transformation will create tremendous conflict in dysfunctional, dying churches. It will be even greater in congregations that perceive themselves as healthy when they are really dying. The worst thing that can happen in the midst of such conflict is mediation, since the conflict is more about the transfer of power and who will lead the congregation, than individuals or groups not being able to get along" (p.33).

“Third, for a congregation to move from dysfunction to health, it usually requires that those in control now can no longer have any say in the direction of the congregation. Yet these people usually perceive themselves to be either the most biblically literate or the most spiritually wise individuals in the congregation, which is why they think they should be in control. After all they usually have hung around the longest, investing the most time and sometimes the most money in the life of the congregation” (p.73).

“We found that by touching structure we created stress, because the changes affected those who, often for years, had been in power, protected turf, and controlled the money and in turn the overall ministry of the congregation. This move exposed those who desired a congregation that was truly interested in reaching out to people versus those who wanted to control things, even if it meant that such control would bring eventual death to the congregation” (pp.94, 95).

Borden’s universal method of dealing with lay members who don’t share his views is to exclude them from influencing the congregation, and if that is not sufficient to silence them, ask them to leave altogether. This methodology avoids actually addressing whether the person is right or wrong in the stand that they have taken, and that is a problem. It is, however, not a new one. The founders of the Adventist Church faced similar methods when they accepted the truth of the nearness of the second coming.

“The minister did not attempt to refer to a single text that would prove us in error, but excused himself on the plea of a want of time. He advised us to quietly withdraw from the church, and avoid the publicity of a trial. We were aware that others of our brethren were meeting with similar treatment for a like cause, and we did not wish it understood that we were ashamed to acknowledge our faith, or were unable to sustain it by Scripture; so my parents insisted that they should be acquainted with the reasons for this request.

“The only answer to this was an evasive declaration that we had walked contrary to the rules of the church, and the best course would be to voluntarily withdraw from it to save a trial. We answered that we preferred a regular trial, and demanded to know what sin was charged to us, as we were conscious of no wrong in looking for and loving the appearing of the Saviour. [THUS, FOR NO REASON OTHER THAN THEIR STEADFAST TESTIMONY REGARDING THEIR BELIEF IN THE SOON COMING OF CHRIST, THE HARMON FAMILY WERE SEPARATED FROM THE METHODIST CHURCH.]”
(Christian Experience and Teachings of Ellen White, p. 44).

If a person is raising objections over sincere and legitimate concerns, that behavior does not constitute grounds for punishment or exclusion from church involvement. On the other hand, if the person is acting against the best good of the congregation out of selfish interest that behavior needs to be actively checked by the congregation. Either way, it simply doesn’t work to sweep the objections under the rug. What the person has to say needs to be fairly and openly considered by the congregation as a whole, which then needs to reach a conclusion about the legitimacy of the statements made and act accordingly. Again, the key words are “fairly” and “openly.” As Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis said, “Sunshine is the best disinfectant.”

“As local congregational leaders began to risk in leading their respective congregations from dysfunction to health, those resisting the change often contacted judicatory leaders. It was at this point we assured these resisters that their congregational leaders were on track and needed their support even when the change produced great pain. For some of the critics our support was enough. When that occurred the change happened more quickly, because the judicatory had thrown its support and credibility behind congregational leaders. Other congregational critics however, were frustrated with our support of their leaders. They in turn went around the judicatory and complained to national leaders. The national leaders by and large did not support the leaders at either the congregational level or the regional level. When this occurred the change process was slowed down considerably. These critics created havoc with members of the congregation by playing their denomination’s leaders against each other. Their actions were much like a child playing parents against each other so the child does not have to do her or his homework” (p.80).

“Tremendous change can occur in a short amount of time when both the pastors and lay leaders are in agreement about making changes and are committed to not allowing individuals within the congregation to drive wedges between them collectively or individually” (p.54).

Here again we see at work the juggernaut that takes no notice of alternate viewpoints and refuses to listen to the wisdom of others. The most significant point it refuses to acknowledge is that if God were really in the changes they would naturally foster a greater unity and zeal for mission, not an atmosphere of friction or stress which must be overcome.

“God is not the author of confusion, but of peace. The selfishness that exalts one man to rule the minds of his fellow men is not inspired of God; for the Lord works in and through those who will be worked by Him, and who in every line of Christian service will act in accordance with divine enlightenment” (Spalding and Magan Collection, p.247).

Scripture sums up this subject quite effectively.

“Having brought the apostles, they made them appear before the Sanhedrin to be questioned by the high priest. ‘We gave you strict orders not to teach in this name,’ he said. ‘Yet you have filled Jerusalem with your teaching and are determined to make us guilty of this man's blood.’

“Peter and the other apostles replied: ‘We must obey God rather than men! The God of our fathers raised Jesus from the dead—whom you had killed by hanging him on a tree. God exalted him to his own right hand as Prince and Savior that he might give repentance and forgiveness of sins to Israel. We are witnesses of these things, and so is the Holy Spirit, whom God has given to those who obey him.’

“When they heard this, they were furious and wanted to put them to death. But a Pharisee named Gamaliel, a teacher of the law, who was honored by all the people, stood up in the Sanhedrin and ordered that the men be put outside for a little while. Then he addressed them: ‘Men of Israel, consider carefully what you intend to do to these men. Some time ago Theudas appeared, claiming to be somebody, and about four hundred men rallied to him. He was killed, all his followers were dispersed, and it all came to nothing. After him, Judas the Galilean appeared in the days of the census and led a band of people in revolt. He too was killed, and all his followers were scattered. Therefore, in the present case I advise you: Leave these men alone! Let them go! For if their purpose or activity is of human origin, it will fail. But if it is from God, you will not be able to stop these men; you will only find yourselves fighting against God’”
(Acts 5:27-39).

Friday, May 14, 2010

Bullseye: Attitudes Towards Clergy

We now come to one of the stickiest issues to be addressed in this series—the treatment of people. On this subject there are two categories of people, clergy and laity. Borden advocates markedly different attitudes and allowances when dealing with pastors than when dealing with lay leaders. We agree that it is appropriate to make that distinction, but on somewhat different grounds and with very different results than Borden does. Because of the volume of statements Borden makes on this subject we are going to give it two posts. This one will address treatment of pastors. The next will get into the treatment of volunteer leaders and rank and file members.

So why the distinction? As we pointed out in our previous post on unsubstantiated statements, Borden believes that pastors are due special honor and consideration simply by virtue of their being leaders. He therefore starts by giving them the benefit of the doubt.

“I always assume the best in every cluster meeting of every pastor regardless of how poorly the pastor thought about his or her ability to lead. I constantly envisioned a better future and what these pastors would be doing some day to lead healthy, growing, and effective ministries. I believed they all could develop as leaders. Some might develop better than others and accomplish more as leaders; however I really did believe they each could improve. I found that by treating pastors this way and expecting the best, they did improve and some have even surpassed my greatest expectations for them” (p.110).

“It is important to state at this juncture that we always went into the consultation supporting the pastor and attempting to conduct the consultation to prepare the pastor to be the primary leader of change” (p.86).

Borden also allows that when an individual pastor or congregation has been underperforming in spreading the gospel the problem may simply be a lack of training in the skills needed to accomplish the task. He responds supportively by offering training and resources and encouraging the pastors to grow their newly acquired skills through use.

“By changing the title of area minister to area consultant, accompanied by new expectations, we now had the moral obligation to provide these individuals with the resources required to accomplish their new responsibilities and meet the new expectations” (p.42).

"Our goal was not to lose pastors over this decision but have them step up to the task of being a leader who would take risks and be willing to be held accountable for fruitful ministry. We also assured them that if they took such risks the region was not going to abandon them. In the past when congregations had conflicts, it was often easier to have the pastors leave, and the region was known for advocating this. We knew that change would bring conflict, and we assured the pastor that when the conflict came, we would help the pastor deal with the dragons in the congregation who did not want health and growth because it affected their ability to hold influence in the congregation" (p.49).

The support Borden encourages for pastors goes well beyond the traditional understanding of that term, becoming “protection.” This manifests in various ways, from helping pastors “deal with” lay members who don’t fall in line to running interference between pastors and other denominational leaders who might become concerned with their conduct and seek to counsel them.

“Third, we wanted the pastor to help us understand what we would encounter during the consultation weekend and who would be the most resistant to change and why that was so. Fourth, we wanted to know how we could help the pastor deal with those people most resistant to change” (p.88).

“I also served pastors by being a regional representative who would come into their congregation when needed and speak the truth to people who still behaved in dysfunctional ways” (p.109).

“I also saw my role as protecting the pastor and leaders from any undue denominational pressure” (pp.78, 79).

Ultimately, Borden recognizes that some pastors simply aren’t capable of bringing about health and growth in a congregation.

“Another implication of fulfilling our mission is that we are willing to confront pastors who are ineffective” (p.32).

“Sometimes protecting congregational leaders meant meeting with pastors to remind them that, since they now had both the authority and responsibility for ministry, if goals were not met they were accountable and could not shift the blame to others” (p.98).

“In our congregational consultations our goal was to establish the pastor as the leader of the congregation. At the same time the pastor had to be willing to be held accountable for specific missional goals. If the goals were met the pastor was given even more freedom to lead. If the goals were not met, then the pastor needed to realize that perhaps a different calling and vocation was in the pastor’s future” (p.97).

Our reasons for making the distinction between pastors and lay membership are rather different. First, a pastor’s influence is much greater and more far-reaching than a lay member’s. Second, the pastor is the official representative of the denomination both within the congregation and to those outside of it. Third, a pastor receives a paycheck for his religious work. Finally, a pastor is also a regular member (and the two roles are not interdependent). Each of these distinctions contributes to making the way a pastor should be treated different than the way a lay member should be treated.

“Heaven is watching to see how those occupying positions of influence fulfill their stewardship. The demands upon them as stewards are measured by the extent of their influence” (Gospel Workers, p. 495).

A pastor’s larger influence means that both their successes and their errors have much greater impact. Consequently, their behavior must meet an even higher standard than lay members are held to so that their actions don’t lead people away from Christ rather than toward Him. Also, as an official representative of the denomination a pastor’s actions reflect not only on him but on the entire denomination.

“God's servants have to deal plainly, act openly, and not cover up wrongs; for they are standing between the living and the dead and must render an account of their faithfulness, their mission, and the influence they exert over the flock of which the Lord has made them overseers” (Early Writings, p.99).

“Those who profess to be servants of the living God must be willing to be servants of all, instead of being exalted above the brethren, and they must possess a kind, courteous spirit. If they err, they should be ready to confess thoroughly. Honesty of intention cannot stand as an excuse for not confessing errors. …Those who profess to be teachers should be patterns of piety, meekness, and humility, possessing a kind spirit, to win souls to Jesus and the truth of the Bible. A minister of Christ should be pure in conversation and in actions. He should ever bear in mind that he is handling words of inspiration, words of a holy God. He must also bear in mind that the flock is entrusted to his care, and that he is to bear their cases to Jesus, and plead for them as Jesus pleads for us with the Father. I was pointed back to the children of Israel anciently and saw how pure and holy the ministers of the sanctuary had to be, because they were brought by their work into a close connection with God. They that minister must be holy, pure, and without blemish, or God will destroy them. God has not changed. He is just as holy and pure, just as particular, as He ever was. Those who profess to be the ministers of Jesus should be men of experience and deep piety, and then at all times and in all places they can shed a holy influence” (Early Writings, pp.102, 103).

As with any other form of employment, a pastor’s employers have a right to expect the pastor to earn his paycheck through the accomplishment of certain predetermined duties, and if those duties are not fulfilled they have the right to terminate the employment. Such a termination does not conflict with our assertion in a previous post that there is no such thing as an expendable soul, because terminating a pastor’s employment in no way impacts his standing as a regular member of the church or implies that he is no longer welcome to be active in outreach. The only thing that changes (assuming the termination was for ineffectiveness rather than some sort of moral or ethical transgression) is that the former pastor is no longer paid for his efforts and must therefore have some other source of income.

“Those who give themselves to the ministry of the Word enter a most important work. Some have made a mistake in receiving ministerial credentials. They ought to take up work for which they are better adapted. Their efforts are feeble, and they should not continue to receive pay from the tithe. In many ways the ministry is losing its sacred character” (Review and Herald, October 6, 1904 par. 17).

Our point here is not that we are, or should be, “out to get” pastors—we are simply saying that with pastors the stakes (and therefore the consequences) are higher. We have no problem with Borden’s approach of assuming the best in pastors until proven otherwise. (In fact, we believe this principle should be applied to all people, but that’s straying into the topic of our next post.) What we do take issue with is Borden’s concept of “protecting” pastors, as the behaviors he recommends for accomplishing this goal often require treating lay members badly. He goes so far as to refer to pastors leading congregations through change as “velvet covered bricks” (p.120). This hardly strikes us as modeling Christ-like behavior to a congregation.

“Do not lead with harshness and severity, but with respect, kindness, confidence, and love.--You do not feel under sound obligation to God to be patient and kind and respectful toward your ministering brethren and toward every member of the church. They lose confidence in you and then your influence is crippled. You need the kindness, courtesy, meekness, and lowliness of Christ. You have many valuable qualifications that can be perfected for highest service if sanctified to God. You should feel the necessity of approaching your brethren with kindness and courtesy, not with harshness and severity. You do not realize the harm you do by your sharp, domineering spirit toward them.--EGW'88 245” (Pastoral Ministry, p.53).

“There is a most fearful, fatal deception upon human minds. Because men are in positions of trust, connected with the work of God, they are exalted in their own estimation, and do not discern that other souls, fully as precious in the sight of God as their own, are neglected, and handled roughly, and bruised, and wounded, and left to die” (Testimonies to Ministers, pp. 357, 358).

Then, of course, there is the question of whether a pastor acting in accordance with God’s will would really need human protection.

“That same night the LORD said to him, ‘Take the second bull from your father's herd, the one seven years old. Tear down your father's altar to Baal and cut down the Asherah pole beside it. Then build a proper kind of altar to the LORD your God on the top of this height. Using the wood of the Asherah pole that you cut down, offer the second bull as a burnt offering.’

“So Gideon took ten of his servants and did as the LORD told him. But because he was afraid of his family and the men of the town, he did it at night rather than in the daytime.

“In the morning when the men of the town got up, there was Baal's altar, demolished, with the Asherah pole beside it cut down and the second bull sacrificed on the newly built altar!

“They asked each other, ‘Who did this?’ “When they carefully investigated, they were told, ‘Gideon son of Joash did it.’

“The men of the town demanded of Joash, ‘Bring out your son. He must die, because he has broken down Baal's altar and cut down the Asherah pole beside it.’

“But Joash replied to the hostile crowd around him, ‘Are you going to plead Baal's cause? Are you trying to save him? Whoever fights for him shall be put to death by morning! If Baal really is a god, he can defend himself when someone breaks down his altar.’ So that day they called Gideon ‘Jerub-Baal,’ saying, ‘Let Baal contend with him,’ because he broke down Baal's altar” (Judges 6:25-32).

When religious conflict arises it is not God or His servants who need human protection, but rather the human systems that have been set up in opposition to God.

Monday, May 10, 2010

Bullseye: Unsubstantiated Statements

Throughout Hit the Bullseye Borden makes a great many assertions that he fails to substantiate. This post is devoted to listing these assertions. As the fallacy of many of these statements is self-evident we will not bother to respond to every single one of them. We will be addressing the most egregious.

“Seminaries and denominational systems do not teach or train people to do effective ministry or to be leaders. (I do not believe that leadership development should be the job of seminaries, even though most claim to do it while ignoring the reality that they do not.)” (p.50).

“The New Testament speaks of the gift of leadership and most, if not all, of the New Testament epistles were written to leaders. The assumption of the biblical writers is that the leaders would bring about the changes they were addressing in their epistles. If the people are not following then either we are not leading as we are capable, we do not know how to lead, or we simply are not leaders and need to step away from leadership positions. Leadership has at least one simple test: Is anyone following or not?” (p.57).

“The traditional model of leadership that we have held up for pastoral leaders, a perverted model of shepherding, is not only unbiblical but quite ineffective. It produces small inwardly focused congregations that basically give into a consumer mindset of taking care of the blessed before reaching out to those who are spiritually sick and desperate” (p.106).

“We also needed to protect pastors, lay leaders, and even congregations from other pastors, congregations, and denominational leaders” (p.99).

“First, we must get back to honoring leaders and placing a New Testament value on leadership” (p.141).

“I find that all polities inhibit mission and create a conspiracy of smallness that has come to be valued at the expense of effective ministry” (p.140).

“Therefore, I believe we need to look at flexible polities that fit the requirement of biblical principles about mission, rather than trying to prop up idealized structures that reflect agrarian life in past centuries” (p.141).

“In essence we painted a contrast. The choice was the eventual death of both congregations and the region, or a new life that would produce even greater ministry effectiveness than had ever been seen by congregations within the region. When viewed from that perspective the choice was not difficult” (p.69).

Here we come to the statements that need to be examined more closely.

“One [bureaucracy-producing value] was the belief that many people needed to have their say on a number of matters, whether they were equipped or qualified to speak” (p.75).

“These leaders also want to make sure that every voice is heard. There is a failure to understand that, while every person is equal in his or her standing with and before God, not every voice carries equal weight” (p.61).

“Finally, we must get away from the notion in congregational life that everyone has an equal say. Everyone has equal standing before God in Jesus Christ. However, the right to speak and influence congregational life and behavior should be granted in proportion to one’s maturity as a disciple and ministry as a servant” (p.142).

These three statements have a common theme: it’s OK to exclude people from the decisions of the church. This raises the troubling question, “Who should get to decide who has a say and who doesn’t?” The only legitimate answer is, “No one.” Consider the following biblical story.

“After this, the Moabites and Ammonites with some of the Meunites came to make war on Jehoshaphat. …Alarmed, Jehoshaphat resolved to inquire of the LORD, and he proclaimed a fast for all Judah. The people of Judah came together to seek help from the LORD; indeed, they came from every town in Judah to seek him.

“Then Jehoshaphat stood up in the assembly of Judah and Jerusalem at the temple of the LORD in the front of the new courtyard and said: ‘O LORD, God of our fathers, are you not the God who is in heaven? You rule over all the kingdoms of the nations. Power and might are in your hand, and no one can withstand you…

“‘But now here are men from Ammon, Moab and Mount Seir, …we have no power to face this vast army that is attacking us. We do not know what to do, but our eyes are upon you.’

“All the men of Judah, with their wives and children and little ones, stood there before the LORD.

“Then the Spirit of the LORD came upon Jahaziel son of Zechariah, the son of Benaiah, the son of Jeiel, the son of Mattaniah, a Levite and descendant of Asaph, as he stood in the assembly.

“He said: ‘Listen, King Jehoshaphat and all who live in Judah and Jerusalem! This is what the LORD says to you: 'Do not be afraid or discouraged because of this vast army. For the battle is not yours, but God's…’”
(2 Chronicles 20:1-15).

An ordinary guy is God’s chosen messenger. What would have happened if Jehoshaphat had refused to listen because Jahaziel wasn’t important enough to truly have a message to deliver from God? The Bible simply doesn’t support Borden’s exclusionary philosophy. Even further, both the Bible and the Spirit of Prophesy urge believers not to allow their judgment to be subjected to any other individual. “Let no one despise your youth, but set an example in speech and conduct” (1 Tim. 4:12). “My son, preserve sound judgment and discernment, do not let them out of your sight” (Prov. 3:21).

“Religious teachers read the Bible in the light of their own understanding and traditions; and the people do not search the Scriptures for themselves, and judge for themselves as to what is truth; but they yield up their judgment, and commit their souls to their leaders. The preaching and teaching of His word is one of the means that God has ordained for diffusing light; but we must bring every man's teaching to the test of Scripture. Whoever will prayerfully study the Bible, desiring to know the truth, that he may obey it, will receive divine enlightenment. He will understand the Scriptures. ‘If any man willeth to do His will, he shall know of the teaching.’ John 7:17, R. V.” (The Desire of Ages, p.459).

“It is a fact widely ignored, though never without danger, that error rarely appears for what it really is. It is by mingling with or attaching itself to truth that it gains acceptance. …The mind that depends upon the judgment of others is certain, sooner or later, to be misled.

“The power to discriminate between right and wrong we can possess only through individual dependence upon God. Each for himself is to learn from Him through His word. Our reasoning powers were given us for use, and God desires them to be exercised. ‘Come now, and let us reason together’ (Isaiah 1:18), He invites us. In reliance upon Him we may have wisdom to ‘refuse the evil, and choose the good.’ Isaiah 7:15; James 1:5”
(Education, pp. 230, 231).

“We cannot, we must not, place blind confidence in any man, however high his profession of faith or his position in the church. We must not follow his guidance, unless the Word of God sustains him. The Lord would have His people individually distinguish between sin and righteousness, between the precious and the vile” (Signs of the Times, Aug. 17, 1882).

This brings us to another of Borden’s unsubstantiated statements.

“We will have the eternal opportunity to sit at the feet of Jesus Christ and be taught. However, our God has only given us one lifetime to make disciples for Jesus Christ” (p.138).

His argument here is that believers should use the time that they have previously spent deepening their knowledge of God to do outreach instead. Outreach is important, certainly, but in order to teach others about God we must first know something of Him ourselves. God is not pleased when we stop studying and growing in our knowledge of and experience with Him.

“Brothers, I could not address you as spiritual but as worldly—mere infants in Christ. I gave you milk, not solid food, for you were not yet ready for it. Indeed, you are still not ready. You are still worldly” (1 Cor. 3:1-3).

“In fact, though by this time you ought to be teachers, you need someone to teach you the elementary truths of God's word all over again. You need milk, not solid food! Anyone who lives on milk, being still an infant, is not acquainted with the teaching about righteousness. But solid food is for the mature, who by constant use have trained themselves to distinguish good from evil” (Heb. 5:12-14).

“Like newborn babies, crave pure spiritual milk, so that by it you may grow up in your salvation” (1 Pet. 2:2).

“It is proper and right to read the Bible; but your duty does not end there; for you are to search its pages for yourselves. The knowledge of God is not to be gained without mental effort, without prayer for wisdom in order that you may separate from the pure grain of truth the chaff with which men and Satan have misrepresented the doctrines of truth. Satan and his confederacy of human agents have endeavored to mix the chaff of error with the wheat of truth. We should diligently search for the hidden treasure, and seek wisdom from heaven in order to separate human inventions from the divine commands. The Holy Spirit will aid the seeker for great and precious truths which relate to the plan of redemption. I would impress upon all the fact that a casual reading of the Scriptures is not enough. We must search, and this means the doing of all the word implies. As the miner eagerly explores the earth to discover its veins of gold, so you are to explore the word of God for the hidden treasure that Satan has so long sought to hide from man. The Lord says, ‘If any man willeth to do his will, he shall know of the teaching.’ John 7:17, Revised Version” (Review and Herald, September 11, 1894 par. 2).

To conclude this subject, we can only say as Jesus did that, “You should have practiced the latter without leaving the former undone” (Luke 11:42). The believer must be an active participant in both outreach and personal Bible study.

Wednesday, May 5, 2010

Bullseye: Unit of Mission

“We assume that people leading middle judicatories must believe that the local congregation is the basic unit of mission in the world” (p.14).

We beg to differ. The basic unit of mission in the world is the individual. The Great Commission was given not to a congregation or organization, but to individuals.

“Each individual has a mission to fulfill which involves weal or woe to some other soul. If faithful to his trust, he is a light that shines to God's glory; by his Christian example, his constancy and fidelity, he represents Christ to the world. If he is unfaithful, he becomes a false light, an agent of Satan to allure souls to ruin. As the sentinel who sleeps at his post endangers the liberty and life of his comrades, so does the professed Christian who is untrue to his high calling endanger the eternal welfare of his fellow-men” (Review and Herald, April 24, 1883 par. 3).

“Letters come to me from near and from far, asking for definite instruction in regard to individual duty. I gladly refer these inquirers to the words of Christ, spoken just before His ascension to heaven. ‘And Jesus came and spake unto them, saying, All power is given unto Me in heaven and in earth. Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost: teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you; and, lo, I am with you alway, even unto the end of the world’” (Jehovah Is Our King, pp.5, 6).

Whether the basic unit of mission is the congregation or the individual may not seem significant at first, but the position taken on this point has consequences for how other issues are approached. Here is how Borden presents the logical outgrowths of treating the congregation as the basic unit of mission.

“Obviously relationships are important, but relationships are not the primary purpose for local congregations existing, just as sports teams do not exist so the team members can develop a sense of family” (pp.39, 40).

If the basic unit of mission is the congregation, then individuals become expendable and, as with sports teams, can and should be replaced if they are not "benefiting the team" sufficiently. We find that logical conclusion unacceptable. “For what shall it profit a man, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul?” (Mark 8:36). There is no such thing as an expendable soul. If souls were expendable there would be no need to spread the gospel in the first place. Each soul is of infinite value.

“The larger plans will be laid at the right time; but personal, individual effort and interest for your friends and neighbors, will accomplish much more than can be estimated. It is for the want of this kind of labor that souls for whom Christ died are perishing. One soul is of infinite value; for Calvary speaks its worth. One soul, won to the truth, will be instrumental in winning others, and there will be an ever-increasing result of blessing and salvation” (Review and Herald, March 13, 1888 par. 9).

“Upon every individual who has had the light of present truth devolves the duty of developing that truth on a higher scale than it has hitherto been developed. The Lord will hold us accountable for the influence we might have exerted, and did not because we did not earnestly try to understand our accountability in this world. We need not think that because we are only a tiny light, we need not be particular about shining. The great value of our light lies in its shining amid the moral darkness of the world,--in shining not to please and glorify ourselves, but to honor God. If we are doing service for God, and our work corresponds to the ability God has given us, that is all he expects of us” (Review and Herald, September 21, 1897 par. 2).

This doesn’t mean that the individual should be completely independent of the congregation. The congregation acts as training ground, resource depot, sounding board, support network, and amplifier. It is a well-known fact of group dynamics that the total amount of work a group can accomplish together exceeds the totaled amounts of work that could be accomplished by all of the individuals of that group working separately. This is why individuals band together into congregations, congregations band together into conferences, etc. We work more effectively together than apart, but it all starts with the individual.

“We cannot expect that ministers will be permanently located in settled charges, as they are located in other denominations; but each church member must individually learn to bear responsibility, and become a worker, making the advance of the cause of truth the first and highest interest of his life. Each one must devote his God-given power to the work of God; for every one has a part to act if the church is to be successfully established and carried on. The ignorance and inexperience of church members in regard to their duty in the church cannot be pleasing to God” (Review and Herald, October 22, 1889 par. 2).

Borden presents another logical outgrowth of treating the congregation as the basic unit of mission, namely that the congregation should receive primacy in attention and resources.

“A judicatory intentionally decides to expend the majority of its financial, time, and human resources on meeting congregational needs rather than fulfilling institutional and denominational demands” (p.15).

“Given the obvious scarcity of resources and competition for dollars, it also may mean that some dollars that have normally come to the denomination may need to stay with the congregation for it to have the resources to grow” (p.15).

“Our commitment to the mission and vision took precedence over everything including those specific denominational concerns that we felt hindered the accomplishment of the mission and achieving the vision” (p.63).

This is yet another consequence that we take a rather dim view of. To start with, it isn’t entirely clear what all these extra resources would be needed for. Borden does suggest that congregations would need extra funds to attract and hire a higher quality of pastor, but that particular need doesn’t exist within the Adventist system. Beyond that, the sort of individual to individual evangelism which is most effective really doesn’t require much of a budget, if any at all. Further, the question begs asking what “institutional and denominational demands” are to be sacrificed to free up all these additional funds. Is worldwide mission work to be sacrificed? Or perhaps our worldwide system of hospitals and clinics which spread our health message and thereby open hearts to the gospel? Frequently the Adventist proponents of Borden’s philosophies have targeted our educational system—seeking to close the schools that work to win the hearts of our youth for God during the ages when they are most receptive to the message. In our view none of these “institutional and denominational demands” are expendable. Some of these functions might conceivably be taken over by the local congregation with its new primacy and funding priority, but for the most part a local congregation simply cannot accomplish these things as effectively as the denomination at large can.

"If the enterprise is under control of the General Conference, the way is open for deliberate counsel and a careful consideration of the matter, and if it is undertaken, there will be a united force to give it influence and standing, and this will contribute largely to its success. Under such management, a class of workers could be enlisted that otherwise could not be secured, and thus the enterprise would prosper when it would prove a failure in ordinary hands. And furthermore, there must be an authority to guard such an institution, so that persons who are not qualified shall not be allowed to grasp responsibility through selfish ambition…” (General Conference Daily Bulletin, January 30, 1893 par. 5).

Borden also spends considerable time discussing what he considers to be the differences between the operational mentalities of large and small congregations. “Larger congregations are not simply smaller congregations that now have more people attending” (p.58). His position is that small congregations put their emphasis on people and status at the expense of effective function, whereas big congregations are able to view the work objectively and make good functional decisions because they don’t allow it to get personal. He believes that the line between big and small congregations occurs when a congregation has 200 people in regular attendance.

“In North America most small congregations are small and remain that way because they are spiritually and organizationally dysfunctional. Many large congregations have become large as a result of pursuing organizational health and in many cases spiritual health as well. If small congregations are truly healthy they will not remain small, but will grow and reproduce in one way or another. If a large congregation becomes unhealthy, it will eventually decline” (p.59).

We have no problem with the assertion that health will translate into growth, but we don’t buy into Borden’s blanket portrayal of smaller congregations.

“These are the congregations that in our day have become large and have the opportunity and ability to change communities. The criticism we often hear of such congregations is that they are a mile wide and an inch deep. Yet often those offering the criticisms are involved in congregations that are an inch wide and an inch deep. Our denominational polities have created organizations that promote a conspiracy of smallness that allows a handful of controllers to focus the church on membership privileges that are defined by their personal and family needs and desires” (p.141).

A conspiracy of smallness? The paranoia expressed in this statement defies logical rebuttal beyond pointing out that it is a statement of paranoia. God blesses congregations of many sizes, but His emphasis is not on congregations, but on people. It is people that He came to save, not congregations, and it is through individual believers that His work is carried forward.

“The believer in Christ is consecrated to high and holy purpose. Before the service of the royal priesthood the glory of the Aaronic priesthood is eclipsed. Called according to God's purpose, set apart by grace divine, invested with Christ's righteousness, imbued with the Holy Spirit, offering up the sacrifices of a broken and contrite heart, the true believer is indeed a representative of the Redeemer. Upon such a worshiper, God looks with delight. He will let his light shine into the chambers of the mind and into the soul-temple if men, when they lack wisdom, will go to their closets in prayer, and ask wisdom from him who gives to all men liberally and upbraids not. …As the sinner's sincere, humble prayers ascend to the throne of God, Christ mingles with them the merits of his life of perfect obedience. Our prayers are made fragrant by this incense. Christ has pledged himself to intercede in our behalf, and the Father always hears his Son. Pray then; pray without ceasing; an answer is sure to come” (Review and Herald, October 30, 1900 par. 7).

Friday, April 30, 2010

Bullseye: Corporate Distinctiveness

One aspect of Paul Borden’s approach to church growth which we have brushed against a few times but not yet directly addressed is his minimizing of the distinctiveness of the various denominations in order to impose a one-size-fits-all diagnosis and solution on the congregations he consults with. He goes so far as to openly state, “Our beliefs about God, Jesus Christ and God’s Church may need to change if we are to see our congregations change” (p.19). While this fits in very nicely with the popular secular opinion that all denominations, and even all religions, are merely different paths to the same goal, this approach is deeply troubling to those who do actually believe in the existence of absolute truth.

We are Seventh-day Adventists because we believe that the Adventist Church correctly interprets the Word of God and His intentions for our lives. We also believe that this makes the distinctive features of Adventism more correct and more desirable than those of other denominations or religions. We assume that Baptists would hold the same view of the Baptist Church, as would Methodists about the Methodist Church, Hindus about Hinduism, etc. Our point is not to get into a theological analysis about which denomination or religion is ultimately superior; our point at this moment is that one chooses to belong to a particular denomination or religion because one embraces the uniqueness of that group as being meaningful, significant, and superior to the alternatives. As such it is not desirable to dismiss those distinctive beliefs lightly. As Scripture says, “Evidently some people are throwing you into confusion and are trying to pervert the gospel of Christ. But even if we or an angel from heaven should preach a gospel other than the one we preached to you, let him be eternally condemned! As we have already said, so now I say again: If anybody is preaching to you a gospel other than what you accepted, let him be eternally condemned!” (Gal. 1:7-9). When an individual is confident that what they believe is true they should not be willing to sacrifice any portion of that truth for even so worthy a goal as more converts.

“When the church stand as God's chosen people should, they will be a peculiar people, zealous of good works. There will be no slackness, no concord with Belial. Oh that we could realize what God's people might now be, had they kept themselves in his love, without any compromise with evil, and had retained the peculiar character that distinguished them, and separated them from the world! In experience, in wisdom, in true holiness, they would be years in advance of what they now are. But as a people our obedience, our devotion, our spiritual attainments, are very far from being in proportion to our privileges, and to our sacred obligation to walk as children of the light” (Review and Herald, October 21, 1884 par. 22).

Apparently Borden was confronted with the same concerns when he began to bring in “outside experts” to consult with and train the Baptist congregations under his jurisdiction. “As one person in our denomination put it, if we keep letting them in we will lose our distinctiveness and heritage” (p.25).

Borden responded, “Since we have been declining and losing people and congregations, perhaps our distinctiveness and heritage need to be reevaluated by people from outside” (p.26). Now, if the “distinctiveness and heritage” being reevaluated are on the order of whether to have popcorn and fruit salad for supper every Saturday night we have no problem with soliciting outside opinions (assuming, of course, that someone would actually care enough to have an opinion on that subject). Cultural habits and human-made traditions without theological impact are open to scrutiny and alteration should they prove to be in the way of mission. Not open for reevaluation is anything on which there is a clear, “Thus says the Lord.”

"Another sin of the mind is that of extolling and deifying human reason, to the neglect of divine revelation. Here, too, we must 'gird up the loins of the mind.' We are living in an age when the minds of men are ever on the stretch for something new. Rightly, directed, and kept within proper limits, this desire is commendable. God has given us in his created works enough to excite thought and stimulate investigation. He does not desire men to be less acute, less inquiring, or less intelligent. But with all our aspirations, and in all our researches, we should remember that arrogance is not greatness, nor is conceit knowledge. Human pride is an evidence, not of strength, but of weakness. It reveals not wisdom, but folly. To exalt reason unduly is to abase it. To place the human in rivalry with the divine, is to make it contemptible" (Review and Herald, January 19, 1886 par. 11).

The task that now falls to us is to determine where this line between negotiable and nonnegotiable falls. More to the point in the current context, on which side of the line is church structure and governance?

“I have often been instructed by the Lord that no man's judgment should be surrendered to the judgment of any other one man. Never should the mind of one man or the minds of a few men be regarded as sufficient in wisdom and power to control the work, and to say what plans should be followed. But when, in a General Conference, the judgment of the brethren assembled from all parts of the field, is exercised, private independence and private judgment must not be stubbornly maintained, but surrendered. Never should a laborer regard as a virtue the persistent maintenance of his position of independence, contrary to the decision of the general body . . . . God has ordained that the representatives of His church from all parts of the earth, when assembled in a General Conference, shall have authority. The error that some are in danger of committing, is in giving to the mind and judgment of one man, or of a small group of men, the full measure of authority and influence that God has vested in His church, in the judgment and voice of the General Conference assembled to plan for the prosperity and advancement of His work” (Testimonies to the Church, Vol. 9, pp. 260, 261).

“Resolved, that the highest authority under God among Seventh-day Adventists is found in the will of the body of that people, as expressed in the decisions of the General Conference when acting within its proper jurisdiction; and that such decisions should be submitted to by all without exception, unless they can be shown to conflict with the word of God and the rights of individual conscience” (Review and Herald, vol. 50, No. 14, p.106).

We have doubtless all heard the saying that “if A equals B, and B equals C, then A must equal C.” In this case “A equals B” is that the highest authority under God among Seventh-day Adventists is a decision by the General Conference in Session, which “should be submitted to by all without exception.” “B equals C” is that the Seventh-day Adventist Church Manual (which spells out the structure for Adventist congregations) is a product of the General Conference in Session, with a new edition issued each time a Session is held. (This happens every five years.) Therefore, “A equals C” is that the Church Manual should be submitted to by all without exception, unless it can be shown to conflict with the word of God and the rights of individual conscience. This puts the structure of Adventist congregations squarely on the nonnegotiable side of the line.

The Spirit of Prophesy speaks of the unfortunate results of humans tampering with the structures and governments designed for them by God in the context of the Children of Israel demanding a king.

“The Hebrews demanded a king of Samuel, like the nations around them. By preferring a despotic monarch to the wise and mild government of God Himself, by the jurisdiction of His prophets, they showed a great want of faith in God, and confidence in His providence to raise them up rulers to lead and govern them. The children of Israel being peculiarly the people of God, their form of government was essentially different from all the nations around them. God had given them statutes and laws, and had chosen their rulers for them, and these leaders the people were to obey in the Lord. In all cases of difficulty and great perplexity, God was to be inquired of. Their demand for a king was a rebellious departure from God, their special leader. He knew that a king would not be best for His chosen people. . . . If they had a king, whose hearts was lifted up and not right with God, he would lead them away from Him, and cause them to rebel against Him. The Lord knew that no one could occupy the position of king, and receive the honors usually given to a king, without becoming exalted, and their ways seem right in their own eyes, while at the same time they were sinning against God.

“God had separated the Israelites from every other people, to make them His own peculiar treasure. But they, disregarding this high honor, eagerly desired to imitate the example of the heathen! And still the longing to conform to worldly practices and customs exists among the professed people of God. As they depart from the Lord they become ambitious for the gains and honors of the world. Christians are constantly seeking to imitate the practices of those who worship the god of this world. Many urge that by uniting with worldlings and conforming to their customs they might exert a stronger influence over the ungodly. But all who pursue this course thereby separate from the Source of their strength. Becoming the friends of the world, they are the enemies of God” (Conflict and Courage, p.146).

So where does all of this leave us? It should leave us with the conclusion that distinctiveness is not something to be ashamed of or minimized. It should also leave us looking to God. He has called us to be His “peculiar” people in any and every sense of that word which suits Him. We are to follow His lead, and not allow the current fads in human wisdom to lure us away from whatever peculiarity He has called us to.

"How can man be just with God? This is the one great question that most concerns mankind. Can human reasoning find an answer?--No; revelation alone can solve this all-important problem, can shed light upon the pathway of man's life. What folly, then, to turn from the one great source of light, the Sun of righteousness, to follow the feeble and uncertain light of human wisdom!" (Review and Herald, January 19, 1886 par. 12).

Monday, April 26, 2010

Bullseye: A Different Medicine

In the previous chapter of this series we observed that, within the Adventist context at least, structure isn’t the problem. This chapter will further explore the Adventist governance structure and how it compares to both the Baptist structure Paul Borden describes and his concept of the ideal church structure.

“And, even American Baptists agree that their denominational structure does not work” (p.29).

We aren’t Baptists, and we don’t claim to be experts on Baptist structure or opinions, but for the sake of argument we are going to assume that this statement is accurate. (The following description of Baptist polity is based exclusively on descriptions provided by Paul Borden. We apologize for any inaccuracy.) Under the Baptist structure, each congregation is an independent entity. It may voluntarily cooperate with other congregations or the higher structure, but it is under no obligation to do so if it is not so inclined. Also, the higher structure has no power or control over the congregation. Baptist congregations hire their pastors and all other paid staff directly. These paid personnel are described as being overseen by numerous boards and/or committees who take no active part in the ministry tasks they monitor, but who act as monetary gatekeepers and strategy assessors. There is, therefore, a separation between the authority to initiate ministry activities and the responsibility for carrying them out. Since the paid personnel are hired and fired by the congregation they must keep in mind the politics and preferences of the congregation in their actions. Borden mentions that as part of his interaction with congregations as a regional leader, “Often I have gone to board meetings and asked the pastor ahead of time what I needed to say that, if the pastor said it, might lead the board to consider dismissing the pastor” (p.109).

So how does Borden’s ideal structure function?

“We turned right side up the biblical model of congregational ministry. This meant that leaders were not hired to do the ministry. Instead they were employed to lead the congregation and equip the saints to do the work of ministry” (p.95).

“The board needed to give up control of leading the congregation to the pastor and the pastor’s staff members. The pastors and the staff members had to give up the control of the ministry to the laity of the congregation. This meant that the congregation needed to be led by staff members who saw their jobs as developing lay people to be disciples and leaders of ministries. Staff members were to equip people for the work of ministry rather than conducting the ministry themselves. The pastor and staff members were to be leaders who developed leaders, who in turn developed more leaders” (p.91).

“This new structure also meant a new way of looking at church boards. Their responsibility was to govern, not manage or lead. They were to focus on the ends of ministry, goals set by the pastor and the pastor’s staff members, not the means of ministry. The day-to-day conduct of ministry became the responsibility of staff members. Board members were taught that their job in relation to the pastor and pastor’s staff members were to be their protectors and cheerleaders. The board also held the pastor accountable each year for the missional goals that had been set by the pastor with the board’s approval. However, the board was not to become involved in the management of the ministry. In fact we encouraged congregations to dissolve all committees and task forces. We encouraged a tradeoff between the effective accomplishment of a mission versus a bureaucracy that gave everyone a say regardless of whether ministry was accomplished effectively or not. In larger congregations we urged the pastor to hire an administrator who would oversee a team of people (both paid and volunteer) to handle many administrative responsibilities. However, this administrator reported to the pastor, not the board” (pp.95, 96).

“Usually after a congregational consultation we encouraged congregations to have smaller boards of no more than three to seven people” (p.118).

To summarize, three to seven people sit on a board that has only two tasks: praise and protect the pastor and see that the pastor follows through on what he says he will do. (Presumably if the pastor does not do what he says he will they have the power to fire him.) The pastor, in turn, is responsible for coming up with big ideas about what the church will accomplish, choosing staff members to whom he can delegate the work, and then making sure they do it. These staff members choose members of the congregation to whom they can pass along this delegation of work and teach these volunteers how to do the work and train others. While called “staff members,” the individuals who answer to the pastor are not necessarily paid personnel.

“This new structure required that congregations of fifty, seventy, or 100 should be staff led. Most staff members were not paid, and if they were not retired they had full-time employment at other jobs during the week. These people were required to set behavioral, specific, and measurable goals for their respective areas of ministry. However, they were also given the complete authority, including the spending of their departmental budget allotments without special permission, to carry out their responsibilities. We trained them to recruit a team of individuals, they would develop as disciples and leaders to work with them. However, we made it quite clear that each staff member would be held accountable for the goals that had been established, not the team. It was, and continues to be, amazing how lay volunteers act when they are treated respectfully as staff members who are given the freedom to direct their ministries in relation to goals. They recruit whomever they want to be on their team and are responsible to see that these individuals get the training they need to be effective in ministry. These staff members no longer see themselves as volunteers, but as people ministering alongside the pastor to accomplish the mission and vision of the congregation. By the way, it is possible to fire such staff members if they fail to meet their goals” (p.96).

It is important to note at this point that creation and administration of the budget is done exclusively by the pastor. If the board of three to seven people believe he is being unreasonable in this regard they may take him to task after the fact, but there are no preventive checks and balances to protect against misuse or even absconding with funds. Such measures would hamper his “freedom to lead.”

“We believed in strong leadership, which meant that once the mission was adopted and once the vision was cast the leader needed to be given the freedom to lead. This meant the leader could not be second-guessed all the time for what she or he was doing to bring a change that would implement the mission and achieve the vision. It meant the leader could not be encumbered with bureaucratic restrictions that either inhibited what needed to be accomplished or slowed it down as it was going through channels. The leader did need to be held accountable, but that accountability needed to be one that related to the accomplishment of goals and results, not the process by which these goals and results were achieved” (p.135).

So how does the Adventist structure vary from either the Baptist system or Borden’s ideal system? The Adventist system is incredibly similar to Borden’s ideal system. There are no passive committees or boards. Everyone elected to the church board is there because they are tasked with the active leadership of a particular ministry. Functionally an Adventist church board meeting is designed to be a staff meeting in which individuals with specific active ministry responsibilities make and coordinate plans and keep each other accountable. (See our earlier post, The Right Way, for a more detailed description of how an Adventist church board functions.) When the size of the ministry warrants it, these ministry leaders have their own “staff” who are elected to assist with the ministry. These subordinates make up the “committee” or “council” for that particular ministry. These committees or councils meet formally or informally, regularly or irregularly, as the ministry leader sees a need in order to accomplish the ministry with which they are tasked. Ministry leaders have considerable discretion over their departmental budgets. Most congregations have safeguards that if a single expenditure is going to exceed a predetermined dollar amount it must be approved by the board, treasurer, or finance committee, but such approval is nearly automatic so long as the expenditure truly pertains to ministry. Unless this dollar amount limitation is tripped, the ministry leader needs no advance authorization to spend their budget.

Unlike Borden’s ideal system, in the Adventist system congregations don’t hire, pay, or fire their pastors. Pastors are hired, paid, and fired by the conference. (The conference also owns all local church property and requires remittance of all tithe funds.) The separation between paycheck source and ministry focus allows pastors to give the sort of unpleasant-but-necessary exhortations Borden admits a Baptist pastor could be dismissed for uttering, among other advantages, but it also has a significant impact on the accountability dynamic he prescribes. In order for a board or other entity to hold an individual accountable they must have some sort of power over that individual. In a perfect world if the board said to the individual, “You need to be working harder on this,” or “We aren’t satisfied with your performance on that,” the individual would immediately work to fix the problem. Realistically, unless the accountability body has some sort of hold over the individual they may not pay much heed to the accountability body. Borden’s ideal system assumes the continuation of the Baptist practice of the pastor being employed directly by the congregation. In this scenario an accountability board does have a hold over the pastor—namely the ability to terminate their employment. Since Adventist congregations do not employ their pastors directly this aspect of Borden’s system doesn’t work in an Adventist context.

“Three key concepts relating to structure must always be kept together in the structure and cannot be separated. Those concepts are authority, responsibility, and accountability. Any individual who is given a specific responsibility must be given adequate authority to accomplish the task. That individual must then be held accountable to ascertain that the responsibility has been fulfilled. Separating authority from responsibility creates frustration, and if accountability is absent, often creates ineffectiveness. Giving someone both authority and responsibility without demanding accountability is both dangerous and foolishness” (p.127).

The Adventist system achieves accountability through the peer pressure of making ministry leaders answer to each other (and the congregation through the electoral process) and by requiring the pastor to get approval for his decisions from the church board. The power to approve or disapprove of his plans is the only hold an Adventist congregation has over its pastor. To adopt in an Adventist congregation the Borden model of giving the pastor complete freedom to do ministry as he sees fit and then have a separate board which inquires about his accomplishments effectively creates the very problem Borden warns against—having authority and responsibility without accountability. This is because under the Adventist system of pastoral hiring an accountability body that looks at performance after the fact is impotent. Even more significant, giving a pastor that degree of freedom is not sanctioned by either biblical precedent or the Spirit of Prophesy.

“Notwithstanding the fact that Paul was personally taught by God, he had no strained ideas of individual responsibility. While looking to God for direct guidance, he was ever ready to recognize the authority vested in the body of believers united in church fellowship. He felt the need of counsel, and when matters of importance arose, he was glad to lay these before the church and to unite with his brethren in seeking God for wisdom to make right decisions. Even ‘the spirits of the prophets,’ he declared, ‘are subject to the prophets. For God is not the author of confusion, but of peace, as in all churches of the saints.’ 1 Corinthians 14:32, 33. With Peter, he taught that all united in church capacity should be ‘subject one to another.’ 1 Peter 5:5” (Acts of the Apostles, p.200).

“When this power which God has placed in the church is accredited to one man, and he is invested with the authority to be judgment for other minds, then the true Bible order is changed. Satan's efforts upon such a man's mind will be most subtle and sometimes overpowering, because through this mind he thinks he can affect many others. Your position on leadership is correct, if you give to the highest organized authority in the church what you have given to one man. God never designed that His work should bear the stamp of one man's mind and one man's judgment” (Testimonies to the Church, Vol. 3, p.493).

The bottom line is that while Borden’s ideal structure may benefit Baptists it is not useful for Adventists to attempt to apply its configurations of authority and accountability exactly as he prescribes them. To use a medical metaphor, giving the blood-thinning medicine prescribed for a heart attack patient to someone suffering from ulcers would not heal the ulcers; it would make them worse. Borden’s prescriptions might be just what the doctor ordered for Baptist congregations, but they only exacerbate Adventist problems.

“Congregations are scared to death to put authority and responsibility together because most believe it will create organizational monsters with dictatorial leaders. This fear is well founded, if there is not clear and powerful accountability” (p.142).

Wednesday, April 21, 2010

Bullseye: Change for Change's Sake

“The creation of new structures will never produce renewal in an organization. Renewal is instigated with a new mission, a compelling vision, and the adoption of new values. However, the change process is never ultimately achieved or solidified without the adoption of a new structure. In fact I would go further and suggest that the adoption of a new structure that is consistent with new mission, vision, and values accelerates the change process. Also failure to adopt a new structure will eventually stifle the implementation of a new mission and vision” (pp.125, 126).

In other words, Paul Borden advocates change simply for change’s sake. He views structure as a merely human institution that is fair game for alteration on the grounds that it won’t do any harm and might do some good. This gratuitous change comes with the added benefit that along the way you’ll be able to identify who’s willing to jump on your bandwagon and who isn’t.

“Therefore a change in structure is a tangible way of determining whether or not people are either embracing or denying new missions, visions, and values. A new structure is both a lightning rod and a thermometer of how well people are accepting or rejecting change. In other words, changes in structures create stress in people and that stress reveals where they stand in relation to the new changes. This phenomenon is why changes in structure that are aligned with new missions, visions, and values are so crucial” (p.126).

The problem with this theory is that being opposed to changes in structure doesn’t automatically mean that one is also opposed to “new missions, visions, and values,” or vice versa. Unfortunately, Borden doesn’t make any distinction between those who desire church growth but also have intellectual and spiritual concerns about the process and those who simply like things the way they are and don’t want to change. Anyone who raises an objection of any kind is classified as “rejecting change.”

As we will discuss later in this series, knowing who is or is not in favor of the changes being made is significant to Borden’s strategy because he advocates actively excluding objectors from having any say at all in the congregation, if possible. This leaves the pastor surrounded by “yes men,” or “cheerleaders,” as Borden puts it. In order to create this dictator’s utopia of unquestioned authority Borden is happy to let leaders bend the rules of their denominations.

“None of the changes I see as fundamental will occur without changes in structure. In some denominations this is harder to do than in others… However, in such cases there may be the need to create shadow structures that are usable and effective, even if they are not recognized officially” (p.18).

Borden assumes that all congregations and denominations, though perhaps possessed of some cosmetic or traditional differences, are essentially the same in terms of attitudes and functionality. He also assumes that all congregations and denominations are facing exactly the same problem in their attempts to grow.

“All current polity systems perpetuate models of governance that lead to organizational hierarchies (some through position and others through tenure) and create bureaucracies. These models of organization are rejected in almost all organizations today except for the church. Almost every congregation I have ever consulted with has told me that their one problem, unique to congregations with their polity, is that they have too many committees. Congregations think that this issue, which is usually described in a polity context, is unique to them. They do not realize that their congregation is simply reflecting what their denomination and judicatories are already doing. Each congregation sees itself imprisoned by their structure and wish they had the structure of another polity when it comes to organization” (p.140).

The practice of ascribing all of a congregation’s problems to a faulty structure has a certain allure. Structures don’t have any feelings to be hurt; no pride to be wounded by being told that they are not performing well. Changes in structure are easy to make and easy to point to as a measure of accomplishment. The difficulty with this approach is that, within the Adventist context at least, structure isn’t the problem. The entire denomination uses the same structure throughout the world. In some places the work is booming and in others it is not. What this tells us is that the problem is not with the effectiveness of the structure, but rather the commitment and effectiveness of the people leading the congregation.

“The fifth issue that is crucial to producing fundamental change in dysfunctional congregations is to create a new structure that is aligned with the new outward focused mission and vision. To do this, you need to do something with the current structure that has contributed to and supports the current state of plateau and decline” (94, 95).

There are two questions Borden fails to ask in making this assertion. The first is whether the congregation in question is strictly adhering to the structure that it claims to follow. (If it is not, the dysfunction could very well be with the implementation of the structure, not its basic makeup.) The second is whether the problem truly lies with the structure or the people. (Changing the structure won’t improve anything if the change that is needed is with the hearts of the people.) As Borden himself states, the creation of new structures will never produce renewal in an organization. If a congregation or pastor is not successful in soul-winning efforts the remedy is not structural change, but personal introspection:

“Here, ministers of Christ, is your Pattern. You are to copy the life and character of the Master. Humility, meekness, and love are to be revealed in your character as they were in his. Your labors need not be without marked results. If they are fruitless you should investigate your own case,--examine yourselves whether you be in the faith. If Christ abide in your hearts, you will go forth, weeping, bearing precious seed, and will doubtless come again with rejoicing, bringing your sheaves with you. You who have labored year after year, and have seen no souls brought to the knowledge of the truth, no churches raised up and organized, should change your manner of labor. You should fast and pray. You should lay the matter before your brethren, and solicit their counsel and prayers, lest you be self-deceived, and, what is more, deceive others also” (Review and Herald, October 21, 1884 par. 18).

Friday, April 16, 2010

Bullseye: Known Associates

Just as people are known by their fruits they are also known by their friends. This post is devoted to the other people and groups Paul Borden mentions in his book as experts, thinkers, and resources that he has either pulled from in forming his own positions or brought in to his own churches to provide training. Rather than analyzing each one we have decided to let you, our readers, come to your own conclusions. We are providing a few links to information about each of these people to get your research started.

George Bullard
http://georgebullard.org/
http://www.thecolumbiapartnership.org/
http://bullardjournal.posterous.com/?page=9

Leith Anderson
http://newsweek.washingtonpost.com/onfaith/panelists/leith_anderson/
http://www.faithminute.org/default/index.cfm/about-us/leith-anderson/
http://www.wooddale.org/default/index.cfm/guest/who-we-are/

John Maxwell
http://johnmaxwell.com/
http://johnmaxwellonleadership.com/
http://www.sermoncentral.com/article.asp?article=a-John_Maxwell_07_23_07&ac=true

Stan Toler
http://www.stantoler.com/sitev3/subpages/pages.shtml?resources/message-index.shtml
http://www.nazarene.org/ministries/superintendents/display.aspx
http://southarkansasdistrict.org/Officers.aspx

Herb Miller
Unfortunately, “Herb Miller” proved to be too common a name for us to locate this individual through web searches without more information about him than was provided in Hit the Bullseye.

Kennon Callahan
http://toolboxforfaith.org/tag/kennon-callahan/
http://www.9marks.org/CC/article/0,,PTID314526_CHID598026_CIID2008780,00.html
http://www.nspeidiocese.ca/stewardshipconference/Callahan.html

Glen Martin
Unfortunately, “Glen Martin” proved to be too common a name for us to locate this individual through web searches without more information about him than was provided in Hit the Bullseye.

Randy Frazee
http://billbolin.org/?p=449
http://www.oakhillschurchsa.org/LoadPageAction.do?mode=view&editId=444
http://www.growthtrac.com/artman/publish/interview-with-randy-frazee-493.php
https://www.navpress.com/author/A10380/Randy-Frazee

John Carver
http://johncarver.com/bib-John.htm
http://www.carvergovernance.com/JohnCarver.htm
http://www.speakers.ca/carver_john.aspx

Saddleback Church
http://www.saddleback.com/
http://www.inplainsite.org/html/saddleback_church.html

Paul Borden qualifies this reference:

“Since we had encouraged many learners to learn from the models of ministry implemented at Saddle Back and Willow Creek, many thought we were leading congregations to accept a seeker-driven model. That simply was not the case, although we urged our congregations to be seeker-friendly and sensitive in the manner in which they conducted corporate ministry. In fact, we went the opposite way, suggesting that they not adopt a seeker-driven model since we believed that leading established congregations into such a model would be counter-productive to change and organizational health. I believed that this change was so drastic that it would inhibit the congregation’s ability to move from dysfunction to health” (p.84).

Note, however, that he is not disagreeing with the approach of Saddleback, just experiencing concern that it could be too radical and destructive for his congregations.

Monday, April 12, 2010

Bullseye: Things We Agree On

Paul Borden’s philosophies on church health and growth are at the heart of the changes being pushed at Takoma Park and throughout the Potomac Conference, and consequently ought to be given a thorough examination. This post starts a new series devoted to doing just that. Paul Borden spells out his philosophies in his book, Hit the Bullseye, and we will be examining this volume in detail. We begin with the points he makes that we agree with, namely the need for accountability, honesty, and urgency. (Unless otherwise noted, all quotes in this series are from Hit the Bullseye.)

“In many denominational and congregational entities there is little counting (other than for budgets), few do ministry accounting, and almost no one is held accountable for anything” (p.36).

“We knew that we could not (and should not) measure conversions…However, we could measure the practices for which we can take more responsibility” (pp.36, 37).

“We have often confused the method of ministry with the nature of the message, and when there have been no results we have honored the faithfulness of the messenger” (p.38).

The Adventist Church in North America has become too forgiving of mediocrity and lack of follow-through from its leaders, both paid and volunteer. We need to get back in the habit of making plans to spread the gospel and be a positive influence in our communities.

“Would that we as a people might realize how much is pending upon our earnestness and fidelity in the service of Christ. All who realize their accountability to God, will be burden-bearers in the church. There can be no such thing as a lazy Christian, though there are many indolent professors of Christianity. While Christ's followers will realize their own weakness, they will cry earnestly to God for strength, that they may be workers together with him. They will constantly seek to become better men and better women, that they may more faithfully perform the work which he has committed to their hands” (Review and Herald, January 19, 1886 par. 5).

“Teach your children that nothing is to be withheld from God, that all their gifts are to be used to promote His glory. Teach them to cherish a sense of their accountability to use wisely their intrusted capabilities, improving and perfecting them by use. They are accountable for the judicious exercise of every faculty” (Signs of the Times, October 18, 1899 par. 6).

Once we have made plans we must follow through with executing them and evaluating the effectiveness both of the plan itself and those specific individuals tasked with seeing it accomplished. Ineffective plans should be abandoned and ineffective individuals either trained for greater effectiveness or given other tasks for which they are more suited. Accomplishing this accountability requires the use of another principle: honesty. Everyone has talents to use for God, but that does not automatically mean that they are using those talents to the best advantage in whatever position they might currently hold.

“Yet while listening and showing respect I wanted the pastor to observe that I did not back away from the truth” (p.112).

“Loyalty is important and valuable if people are loyal to the right cause. Also, a loyalty that is not critical of that to which the person is being loyal may be a human value but it surely is not a spiritual one. If my child commits murder, I will still love and support my child while recognizing that my loyalty to my child does not interfere with the legal system that seeks to bring justice to the situation” (p.73, bold supplied).

Love may be blind, but as Borden says, loyalty should not be. And it doesn’t cease to be loyalty when it is submitted to intellectual scrutiny. Desiring the best for our fellow brothers and sisters in Christ should not prevent us from discerning what they are or are not skilled at, or when they are speaking truth and when error.

“Therefore, you discover what a group’s values are by looking at their behavior; how they spend money, how they treat people, what they do most consistently, what they fail to do unless forced. The values are best seen when the group faces some kind of stress, and then you see how people within the group behave and make decisions” (p.70).

It’s a simple enough principle. “Thus, by their fruit you will recognize them,” (Matthew 7:20). What we do speaks far more loudly about what we believe or value than anything we say, and we as Adventists should be doing far more than we are in living out our belief in the nearness of the second coming.

“Yet the majority of people in our congregations believed that one’s informed faith in Jesus Christ did make an eternal difference” (p.138).

“The lack of mission urgency in North America means that denominational leaders think they still have time to develop modest, incremental strategic plans to tinker with polity, and time afterwards to then go about mission” (p.139).

“…the epitome of service in congregational life is leading ministries that equip new disciples to make more disciples and train them to become leaders” (p.142).

“Let not a day pass in which you do not realize your accountability to work for God, an accountability placed on you by the death of His Son in your behalf. Let not a day pass on which you do not try to heal the wounds that sin has made. Always be found working on the broad plan of God's love” (Pacific Union Recorder, March 13, 1902 par. 6).

Friday, April 9, 2010

The Epic, Pt. 68

After the Group and Pastor DeSilva had each presented their positions to the Executive Committee the meeting was opened for the committee members to ask questions of clarification from either group of presenters. The first major group of questions was directed toward Pastor DeSilva. He was asked how long the new system of governance had been in place and how it was dealing with the eight duties the Church Manual requires the church board to perform, particularly the duty of handling church finances. He responded that the changes had begun in September of 2007, but that the ministries board was really just a continuation of the preexisting church board and performed all the duties the Church Manual requires of a church board. Pastor DeSilva asserted that the requirement for management of church finances was covered by having the chair of the finance committee as a member of the ministries board.

The Group was asked whether it was the name “church ministries board” that we were objecting to, and whether it wasn’t really otherwise already a church board, since many of the people who ought to be on a church board were members of the ministries board. Sister L responded that the problem was not with the name, but with the function. Despite Pastor DeSilva’s claim that the ministries board is performing all the duties specified by the Manual, the official duty list for the ministries board that he prepared falls far short of the Manual’s requirements. She continued that the only part of a governance system that holds up is that which is written down—intent can’t be bottled and passed from person to person. In order for the ministries board to be functioning like a proper church board the official written job description would have to correspond exactly to what is stipulated by the Manual, with all other committees specified as reporting to the ministries board.

Pastor DeSilva was asked whether the ministries board had veto power over reports of the finance committee, and he said that it did. He also observed that the Church Manual makes no specific mention of finance committees, but that in practice bigger churches enlarge the position of treasurer into an entire finance committee. The Group was asked whether having the chair of the finance committee be part of the ministries board didn’t take care of the Manual’s requirement. Sister L answered that the Manual requires the church board to have financial oversight, not merely a member from the finance committee, and reiterated that to be in harmony with the Manual the formal duty list for the ministries board would have to include church finances.

One particularly interesting exchange occurred between Pastor DeSilva and Elder Weigley, the Columbia Union president, who was present at the meeting. Elder Weigley observed that the primary difference between the previous governance and the new Paul Borden system at Takoma Park is that the new system has all committees answer directly to the business meeting, where before they all answered to the church board, which then reported to the business meeting. Pastor DeSilva tried to distance himself from the assertion that Takoma Park’s new system used Paul Borden’s model of governance. He claimed that under Paul Borden’s model the pastor has final authority in the church and chooses all paid and volunteer church leaders. He also claimed that having the accountability board report directly to the business meeting didn’t mean Takoma Park was using Paul Borden’s model, because Borden’s model doesn’t have either accountability boards or business meetings. Elder Weigley shut down Pastor DeSilva’s assertion that the Borden model doesn’t have accountability boards by pointing out that he could show Pastor DeSilva specific passages in Paul Borden’s book, Hit the Bullseye, where he introduces and promotes the concept of accountability boards.

When Pastor DeSilva was asked why he wanted a different system of governance he said that he needed an accountable structure that emphasized ministry. He was also asked whether the structure of the existing board was really so inadequate that he had to create a completely different board to accomplish ministry. He backed off from such an assertion, admitting that to make such a claim would be to deny that anything had been accomplished in his 30 year career working with churches and church boards. When the question was narrowed to inadequacy at the present moment and for the present purpose, Pastor DeSilva replied only that he felt it would be a good change.

The Group was asked what we were willing to give up to reach a solution. Sister L replied that Pastor DeSilva was welcome to have as many specialized committees as he felt a need for, so long as it was clear that they were subcommittees of the church board, not independent entities. The questioning then turned to Pastor DeSilva. He was asked if the accountability board hired people, to which he replied that it functioned as a personnel committee that made recommendations to the business meeting. (He acknowledged that before the new system personnel recommendations had been made to the church board.) Pastor DeSilva was also asked whether the accountability board could function as a subcommittee of the ministries board, to which he replied that it didn’t make sense for an audit committee to be subject to the committee they are auditing.

At that point one of the executive committee members observed that the accountability board could be objective because it was chosen by the nominating committee, not the ministries board. The committee member acknowledged that it would not be desirable for the ministries board to have the ability to alter reports on ministry performance, but wondered why Pastor DeSilva would not want the ministries board to have input on staffing decisions before they were presented to the business meeting. Pastor DeSilva said that for each hire the accountability board invited relevant leaders to participate in their discussions (such as the youth leader when a youth pastor is being selected). The committee member pushed further, asking why the accountability board’s choice could not still be taken back to the ministries board. Pastor DeSilva replied that it was “grossly inefficient” to have a personnel decision discussed by the entire ministries board and appealed to the conference’s system of having a separate personnel committee as an example of such superior efficiency. This line of questioning concluded when another executive committee member pointed out that the conference’s personnel committee still brought its decisions back to the executive committee with full explanations for the choices they made.

Both presentation groups were asked how they would react to having the ministries board adopt the eight point duty list stipulated by the Manual for a church board. Pastor DeSilva’s two associates replied that the ministries board was already doing all eight things and they would have no problem with that functioning being put in writing. Brother X attempted to take issue with the assertion that the ministries board was already performing all eight tasks, but Elder Miller interrupted him and refused to let him address the subject because it was supposedly off topic. When the original question was repeated to the Group Sister L said simply that it would be a good first step, but not a complete resolution of the situation. Elder Weigley picked up on what Brother X had been prevented from saying and asked the Group whether our perception was that the ministries board was not actually performing all the functions on the Manual’s duty list. The Group responded that that understanding was correct.

The Group was asked what its next two biggest concerns were, after the duty list for the ministries board. Sister L responded that the accountability board would still need to be addressed, and that there were some additional issues of lesser significance which hadn’t made it into the presentation. The Group was hoping that these lesser issues would resolve themselves once the larger ones had been addressed, but that it might be necessary to actively deal with them at a later time.

At the end of the meeting the Group was asked whether we were willing to accept whatever recommendation the executive committee might make. Sister L responded that the Group was pursuing a specific goal, that when the recommendation was made the Group would evaluate whether it met that goal, and from that evaluation conclude whether it could accept the recommendation or not. When asked what that goal was Sister L replied that the Group’s goal was to have a system of governance which is completely in harmony with the Church Manual.

Next: Recommendations

Religious

Monday, April 5, 2010

Double Take

Let’s take a closer look at some of Pastor DeSilva’s statements to the executive committee.

Pastor DeSilva began by saying that Paul Borden had been invited by the business meeting to conduct an evaluation. Borden was invited, but that invitation was issued by the church board, not the business meeting (see the Epic, Pts. 1&2). The difference is one of level of authority. Pastor DeSilva was trying to give the impression that there was more power behind the invitation than there really was.

Before explaining his organizational chart Pastor DeSilva stated that charts are never 100% accurate. That may or may not be true, but it is largely irrelevant. Chart perfection might not be possible, but he could have come far closer to complete accuracy had he made the effort. He was hiding behind the statement to excuse poor performance. We also don’t entirely put it past him to have made the charts vague on purpose so that he could reinterpret them at will.

Pastor DeSilva also claimed that the new governance structure was “within the latitude” of the Church Manual. The thing about latitude is that it ends quite abruptly at the designated boundaries. If the posted speed limit for the road we are driving on is 55mph we are permitted to drive at exactly 55mph, or 32mph, or 47mph, etc. We have the latitude to drive at whatever speed we desire—so long as it does not exceed 55mph. This means that 60mph, or even 55.1mph, is not within the latitude. One of the many unfortunate things about this situation is that Pastor DeSilva and his supporters have used the fact that the Church Manual does indeed include some latitude to claim that everything is within the latitude. See our post, In His Own Eyes, for an examination of exactly what latitude the Manual does and does not allow. (Hint: the new governance structure exceeds the latitude granted by the Church Manual).

We have discussed this before (see To Keep It Holy), but Pastor DeSilva’s confused understanding of parliamentary procedure and how to conduct church business manifests again in his description of the process followed to vote the Borden Report. To start with, he describes a motion and a second taken during a town hall meeting (without a final vote). When the church is asked to make a decision of that sort it must be done in a business meeting, which must be announced ahead of time as such. (See p.89 of the Church Manual.) When Pastor DeSilva announced the meeting in advance he described it as a town hall, not a business meeting. If he wanted the church to act on business he should have announced it as a business meeting because that is the term that Adventist congregations understand to be associated with acting on business. Having failed to do that Pastor DeSilva had no right to seek action on any business in the meeting because he had failed to properly announce in advance that business would be acted on.

Further, Pastor DeSilva describes that during the town hall there was a motion and a second, but no vote. Under parliamentary rules, any motion that has not been voted on by the end of a meeting automatically dies. So, even if it had been a duly called business meeting the action taken would be meaningless because it was incomplete and therefore died at the end of the meeting. Finally, Pastor DeSilva described the procedure of having a motion and a second and a delayed vote as being a stipulation of the unvoted motion. Since that motion was not acted on that stipulation also had no force. To summarize, the correct way to do what he did would have been to announce the meeting in advance as a business meeting, make and vote on a separate motion to approve the irregular procedure he wished to follow for this matter only, and then make his motion about the Borden Report. If he had done that his delayed vote on the Borden Report would have been procedurally valid, but he didn’t and it wasn’t.

Pastor DeSilva claimed that Takoma Park had to vote on the Borden Report in its entirety because the report itself said to. Let’s take a quick look at the other things the Borden Report said to do which Pastor DeSilva ignored. First, he ignored all the dates. The report gives 11 separate deadlines for the accomplishment of the various “prescriptions” it makes. Absolutely none of these deadlines were met. The report also calls for a “mission audit” in which all ministries of the church are evaluated for their effectiveness and the ineffective ones are discarded. That never happened. The report also requires that, “The Senior Pastor and Vice-President of Pastoral Ministry will lead the congregation through an envisioning day. … Following that day the pastor and a few other leaders will draft a vision statement.” Long after the deadline for this had passed Pastor DeSilva announced his vision to the ministries board (see the Epic, Pt. 45), but the conference’s vice president for pastoral ministry took no part in the meeting, the congregation was not asked for input before the vision statement was written, and the pastor didn’t involve any other leaders in the preparation of the statement. Given that any similarity between the report’s prescription and what actually happened seems purely coincidental, we’re also putting this one in the “didn’t happen” column. The report says the senior pastor will get a “coach” to help him develop as a leader of a missional congregation. This didn’t happen. The report also says that the pastor and his new board will visit four other growing congregations. This didn’t happen. The report also says that the pastor, staff, and board will attend the Hit the Bullseye conference in Ohio in April 2008. This didn’t happen. So here’s our point: if Pastor DeSilva truly believed that the Borden Report was like the laws of the Persians and Medes in that it could not be changed he would have followed all of these other things to the letter as well. That didn’t happen. He overrode the decision of the business meeting to exclude the structure change from the vote on the Borden Report because he wanted to change the structure. Period. And he was out of line to exert executive authority of that sort which didn’t belong to him.

Finally, Pastor DeSilva claimed that the phrase “staff-led structure” had been misinterpreted to mean a congregational structure. We dispute that this constitutes a misinterpretation. We discussed staff-led structures in our Oct. 2008 post, How does the new structure work?

After the next chapter of the Epic regarding the questions of clarification asked by the executive committee we will be taking a break from the Epic for a new intensive series of posts examining Paul Borden’s book Hit the Bullseye in detail. As part of this series we will take a close look at the staff-led structure he advocates and see that not only is it congregational, but it is that very congregationality which makes it incompatible with Adventist congregations.