Monday, July 26, 2010
The Epic, Pt. 71
When Pastor DeSilva reached the agenda item of addressing the executive committee’s recommendations he went through them one by one, giving his interpretation of each one. He claimed that there was nothing wrong with the way the accountability board was currently functioning, citing Elder Miller’s statements about the lack of consistency about how local churches manage hiring. He argued that since there was no rule about how the hiring was to be done and the accountability board was the church’s personnel committee, that it was alright for it to continue reporting to the business meeting. (In making this argument he ignored two significant points. First, personnel issues are not the only ones delegated to the accountability board, and even if it were acceptable for personnel issues to be reported directly to the business meeting that would not make it acceptable for the accountability board’s other responsibilities to receive the same treatment. Second, even though the conference pointed out that there was no consistency about handling personnel issues the executive committee had still recommended that, “The Support and Accountability Board…reports to the Church Board.”) Pastor DeSilva went on to assert that Elder Miller had told him the configuration of the accountability board was correct because that was the way the church business meeting had voted it. (Again, for the record, the church business meeting had not actually voted it.)
When Pastor DeSilva got to recommendation C (“The primary role of the Church Board is to discuss and plan the evangelism outreach for the church. The newly renamed Church Board should study pp. 90-92 in the manual to make sure the Board functions as stated”) he announced that there was no reason why the church shouldn’t approve it because the church was already doing it. He went so far as to say, “So far as I’m concerned we’re compliant with C right now.”
When the floor was opened for questions Elder B challenged Pastor DeSilva’s assertion that the current governance was compliant with the Church Manual. He responded by asking what was not in compliance. Elder B pointed out that according to the charts of the current governance the senior pastor was above the ministries board. Pastor DeSilva tried to blow that off by claiming that he had no executive function. Next Elder B pointed out that the accountability board reported to the business meeting rather than the ministries board, which he was claiming to be the church board. Pastor DeSilva replied that the accountability board had always reported to the church board. (Not only was this a lie—up to that point the accountability board had not made a single report to the ministries board—it was also a direct contradiction of what he had said a few minutes earlier in claiming that the accountability board could and would continue reporting directly to the business meeting.) Elder B continued by pointing out that the finance committee didn’t report to the ministries board/church board. Pastor DeSilva responded that, “So far as I’m concerned we’ve had finances every meeting that I’ve had.” Seeing that, as usual, Pastor DeSilva was using lies and misdirection to avoid admitting any wrongdoing Elder B didn’t bother to push the point any further.
Sister L was recognized next. She observed that in light of the discrepancies of perception about how the newly-formed church board functioned a temporary subcommittee ought to be formed to create written terms of reference to bring clarity to what the body did and how it did it. Rather than addressing the suggestion Pastor DeSilva chose to focus on and take issue with Sister L’s description of the church board as “newly-formed,” claiming that there had always been a church board at Takoma Park. Sister L tried to refocus him on the substance of the suggestion, but he didn’t want to let go of his complaint that the church board was not “newly-formed.”
At that point Elder Wilson jumped in, asking Sister L whether the suggestion she was making wasn’t already covered under the executive committee’s recommendation D. Sister L pointed out that the purpose of recommendation D was to achieve interpersonal reconciliation, and that it specifically excluded discussion of any issues during the meetings it recommended. (This interjection by Elder Wilson underscores just how little awareness he had of the issues and substance he had been sent to the meeting to observe. We are not accusing him of wrongdoing—it is no crime to be so new to a job that you do not yet know what is going on around you—but his lack of familiarity with the subject at hand made him ineffectual in the task he had been sent to perform on that occasion. Just to remind everyone, that task was to monitor how Pastor DeSilva addressed the executive committee’s recommendations to see that he didn’t ignore them, gloss over them, or sweep them under the proverbial rug. This is a task he could hardly perform when he wasn't even clear on the substance of the recommendations.)
At this point in the discussion Pastor DeSilva took the floor again to deliver what he claimed was a message from Elder Miller. He said that Elder Miller wanted to clarify that he didn’t feel that the executive committee’s recommendations disagreed with the voted intention of the Takoma Park Church regarding its structure and that he believed that the integrity of the church’s vote was intact. Elder Miller was further represented as having said that he didn’t have the authority, or wouldn’t take the authority, to make a recommendation that was contrary to the voted will of a local church in business session and that the changes they were recommending didn’t affect the direction the church had chosen. Pastor DeSilva concluded by claiming that the executive committee was excited about and endorsed the support and accountability council. (Whether these things were actually said by Elder Miller or were only things Pastor DeSilva wished he had said we can’t be sure. No written documentation was presented in support of this “message.” In any case, we have already substantially disproven this argument of the independence of the local church business meeting in Us and Them and What Has Been Done All Along.)
Elder J was recognized, and he expressed concerns about how follow-through on the recommendations would be accomplished. Pastor DeSilva responded that ensuring that the church board was functioning properly would be the responsibility of the accountability board. At this point Elder B asked whether a corrected chart would be produced to accurately depict the relationships of the various governing bodies. Pastor DeSilva returned to his old argument that charts are never 100% accurate. He went on to defend the charts that had been circulating by claiming that there wasn’t actually anything wrong with them; the problem was that people were just reading them wrong. In support of this statement he argued that things are not always as they appear. (This statement is indisputable, especially when Pastor DeSilva is ignoring stated parameters in order to do whatever he wants.) As Elder B pushed the point she referred to the charts as being Pastor DeSilva’s. He jumped on this and claimed that they weren’t his charts; they were voted by the church. (Another lie; none of the governance charts he produced were ever voted by a church business meeting. See the Epic, Pts. 4, 11, 12, and 26.)
Finally, a vote was taken and the recommendations were approved. As soon as the vote was complete Pastor DeSilva pronounced that the issue was now closed. He informed Elder Wilson that since the issue was now closed he expected a letter from the conference endorsing the Takoma Park Church as being in harmony with the Church Manual. He further announced an intention to include such a letter from the conference with one of his own that he would mail to every member of the congregation.
The other significant issue at this meeting of the ministries board was the merger between the elementary school supported by the Takoma Park Church with another local elementary school. The case was made that both schools had been suffering declining attendance in recent years and were occupying old facilities that needed care. The plan was to move the population from one school into the other facility, sell the vacated facility, and use the money to pay off debts and improve the remaining facility. The plan had already been approved by the other school’s church, and all that remained was approval from Takoma Park’s board and business meetings and a constituency meeting of Takoma Park’s school. The ministries board approved the merger. (This issue will be described in greater depth when we get to the story of the school’s constituency meeting.)
Next: At the Business Meeting
Religious
Wednesday, July 21, 2010
What Has Been Done All Along
HOMER TRECARTIN: Mr. Chairman, there is an addition highlighting the interconnected relationship of church organizations…This addition was officially moved and seconded, and the floor opened for discussion.
“There are several organizational levels within the Church leading from the individual believer to the worldwide organization of the work. Membership units in each of these levels periodically convene formal business sessions known as constituency meetings or sessions. (The constituency meeting or session of a local church is generally referred to as a business meeting.) In Seventh-day Adventist Church structure, no organization determines its own status nor does it function as if it had no obligations to the Church family beyond its boundaries.”
[Commenting Delegate #1]: I have a question on the last portion of this particular item. It says, "In Seventh-day Adventist Church structure, no organization determines its own status nor does it function as if it had no obligations to the Church family beyond its boundaries."At this point a delegate expressed the opinion that this statement was too broad and moved that it be referred back to the Church Manual Committee to have the language constricted. That motion was defeated and the discussion continued.
Can you explain why we need that? Have things changed? If so, how?
HOMER TRECARTIN: Mr. Chairman, I’m not sure that it’s because anything has changed, except that there have been several issues that have been dealt with in different areas where it needed to be clear that a local church does not vote itself to be a local church as part of that conference sisterhood of churches. That is voted by the conference. Just as a local conference can’t vote itself into existence, and say we are now part of the sisterhood of unions. Or a local union can’t vote itself into the sisterhood of unions in a division. And so there have been several issues, and it was felt that this clarification was needed to say that no organization in the Seventh-day Adventist Church votes its own status, but also to remind everyone that they have a responsibility to the world church and not just to their own territory.
[Commenting Delegate #2]: This section that we are trying to add here is very important for the church. I am coming from a place where we have people who are trying to become [congregational], and this statement solves that problem of local churches usurping their authority of their conference session. Local churches are trying to work as though they operate without the entire church. They are on their own. In other words, this would protect the church from congregationalism, which some churches in parts of the world would like to assume.After this comment the paragraph was voted on and approved for inclusion in the Church Manual.
The other significant item we would like to highlight was discussed a while later. Again, the item was introduced by Homer Trecartin.
HOMER TRECARTIN: On page 13, lines 4-11, are some additions further explaining the role of the General Conference session and the General Conference Executive Committee. Let me read that paragraph: "The General Conference in SessionThe motion was seconded and discussion began. Some concern was voiced that the relationship between the General Conference and the fundamental beliefs needed to be more clearly stated. Specifically, it needed to be clear that our beliefs come from the Scriptures; the General Conference simply makes formal recognition of biblical tenets that have been identified. This item was eventually referred back to the Church Manual Committee for rewording to clarify this point, but not before the following unrelated and significant exchange took place.
determines the fundamental beliefs of the Church, authorizes establishment of unions and the attachment of field units, revises the Church Manual, elects General Conference and division leadership, performs other functions as outlined
in its Constitution and Bylaws, and considers items referred to it by its Executive Committee. The General Conference Executive Committee between Sessions is empowered by the Constitution and Bylaws to act on behalf of the constituents. Thus Church organizations around the world recognize the General
Conference as the voice of the Church." I would move approval of that addition.
[Commenting delegate #3]: The motion changes the church structure from being largely federal to being central and giving importance to the General Conference. This is being done now in the fifty-ninth session. I just want to know if there is anything that led to this thinking.The Church Manual Committee met during Session to consider items that had been referred back to it by the delegates. They then reported back to the business meeting with any changes made as a result of the consultation. The following is the final form of this paragraph, which was reintroduced to the delegates and approved for inclusion in the new edition of the Manual.
HOMER TRECARTIN: There is no intention of changing the structure of the church. The practice all along has been that our stated fundamental beliefs are approved by the General Conference in session. But the Church Manual didn’t say that. The General Conference session has always elected division leadership and some of these other things, but the Church Manual didn’t say that. And because of various situations that have been arising, we felt it was important that those be clearly stated. It’s not changing anything; it’s just writing down what has been done all along.
The Bible is the foundation and source of belief and practice; on this basis, the General Conference in Session determines the stated fundamental beliefs of the Church. The General Conference in Session also authorizes establishment of unions and the attachment of field units, revises the Church Manual, elects General Conference and division leadership, performs other functions as outlined in its Constitution and Bylaws, and considers items referred to it by its Executive Committee. The General Conference Executive Committee between Sessions is empowered by the Constitution and Bylaws to act on behalf of the constituents. Thus Church organizations around the world recognize the General Conference in Session as the voice of the Church.
“In Seventh-day Adventist Church structure, no organization determines its own status nor does it function as if it had no obligations to the Church family beyond its boundaries.” This statement flies in the face of the interpretation maintained by the Takoma Park pastors and Potomac Conference leadership regarding the local church business meeting’s authority. To paraphrase an old saying, no church entity is an island. Each has relationships and obligations to other entities which are spelled out, among other places, in the Church Manual. We offer the caveat “among other places” because the Manual primarily addresses the relationship between the conference and the local church. Other relationships are described in the Working Policy, etc. All of these policy documents have a common source: the General Conference. “Thus Church organizations around the world recognize the General Conference in Session as the voice of the Church.” And, as Elder Trecartin pointed out, none of this is really new. This is the way the Church has always been understood to operate. The only difference is that these understandings are now being formally articulated to address efforts by some to operate outside the common understanding that has existed all along.
Friday, July 16, 2010
Us and Them
In the Epic, Pt. 69 we promised to explain how the description of Dr. Paterson’s involvement in the formation of the recommendations of the executive committee had been misrepresented by Elder Miller and to provide an analysis of Elder Miller’s presentation to the ministries board.
In the Epic, Pt. 70 we promised to describe the changes in the most recent version of the Church Manual which clarify who has the right to appeal to a union.
Now that all of the pieces of the story bearing on this subject have been told (the subject being the interplay between the local congregation and higher levels of church administration) we are ready to keep these promises and present a consideration of this matter.
It will make most sense if we start with Dr. Paterson’s involvement with the executive committee’s recommendations to the Takoma Park Church. In a conversation some time after the executive committee’s recommendations had been presented Dr. Paterson expressed surprise when members of the Group told him that he had been cited as an authority consulted by the delegation of six from the executive committee as they prepared their recommendations. He declared that he had had no formal discussions with anyone from the conference on the subject of Takoma Park. The only interaction he recalled was an informal chat with Pastor Netteburg and a few others in a restaurant, during which he and Pastor Netteburg discussed what enforcement mechanisms the Church Manual grants to the various levels of the church organization. In that discussion the conclusion that had been reached was that the enforcement mechanism possessed by each level of the church organization is that of disbanding the organization below it.
When Elder Miller had made his presentation to the ministries board his assertion had been that the only power possessed by each level of the church organization was to disband the organization below it. This is a significant difference because in the context of the Church Manual power and enforcement mechanisms are not synonymous. For example, the Church Manual specifies that Bible Instructors may only hold local church office if the conference grants them special permission to do so. (This is to allow them to focus on the particular task of Bible instruction rather than getting caught up in other tasks relating to the local church.) This is a power granted by the Church Manual to the conference. The Manual does not specify any penalty or remedial action (enforcement mechanism) to be used in the event that a local church goes ahead and elects a Bible Instructor to local church office without the conference’s approval (see p.34). The Manual assumes that honorable church members would choose to follow the rules laid out without the need for a penalty to enforce compliance. Therefore, the only scenarios for which the Manual prescribes enforcement mechanisms are those that involve dramatic, flagrant disobedience that calls for severe measures (hence the only enforcement mechanism being disbanding).
Now that we have established that the powers of the various levels of the denominational administration are not so limited as Elder Miller described we need to address what the real boundaries of their powers are. For our purposes we are going to focus that question on the powers pertaining to governance and the Church Manual. We have already discussed the origins of the Church Manual’s authority and the force of its prescriptions in Power (posted 8-28-09), In His Own Eyes (posted 1-7-10), and most recently Bullseye: Corporate Distinctiveness (posted 4-30-10). Rather than repeating those in-depth examinations of the subject we will simply summarize that the authority of the General Conference supercedes that of any other level of the church, including the local congregation. Therefore, any directives generated by the General Conference (which include the Church Manual) are considered binding to the local congregation.
In his presentation to the ministries board Elder Miller had represented the power of the business meeting of the local church as being all but absolute. In reality, there are some limitations. The most notable of these is that the local business meeting cannot adopt any policy or doctrine which is contrary to those held by the worldwide Seventh-day Adventist Church. An example of such a decision which the Group has previously used is that the local church business meeting cannot decide to stop remitting tithe to the conference. To do so would be to declare that it no longer wished to be a Seventh-day Adventist congregation, at which point the conference would have legitimate cause to utilize its enforcement mechanism and disband the congregation. Conversely, there is one matter on which the business meeting has power which the conference is not permitted to exercise. This is the power of deciding issues of discipline. (Discipline is a subject that has "nipped at the heels" of this conflict for some time. We will be addressing it separately in the not-too-distant future.) But again, this power is granted to the local church by the Church Manual, which is a product of the General Conference. It is therefore through the authority of the General Conference that the local church exercises this power—not through the possession of some absolute authority of its own.
So what about this appeal process? The 17th edition of the Church Manual (voted by the 2005 GC Session) puts it this way, “Churches should look to the local conference for advice pertaining to the operating of the church or on questions arising from the Church Manual. If mutual understanding or agreement is not reached, the matter should be referred to the union for clarification” (p.xxii). The meaning of “churches” in this context, and who is responsible to do the referring to the union, are the points of interpretation which could not be agreed upon by the experts consulted about the Group’s situation.
The 18th edition of the Church Manual (voted by the 2010 GC Session) rephrases the statement, “Church officers and leaders, pastors, and members should consult with their conference for advice pertaining to the operating of their congregation or on questions arising from the Church Manual. If they do not reach mutual understanding, they should consult with their union conference/mission for clarification” (p.20).
There are several points about these statements that should be noted. First, neither edition expressly states (or even implies) that when questions arise regarding the Church Manual that a protocol based on Matthew 18 must be followed. The first step called for once it is clear that a question exists is for the questioning parties to consult the conference. Therefore, all of the extra steps that the Potomac Conference insisted on in our situation had no basis in official Church policy. Second, it is the Church Manual, which is an expression of the will of the General Conference, that delegates primary responsibility for answering questions about the Church Manual to the local conferences. This is a practical measure taken simply because the General Conference couldn’t possibly directly address every single question that might arise in local congregations regarding the Church Manual. However, the simple fact that the General Conference exercises its authority to delegate this task to the local conference means that they also have the authority to take back the responsibility should they see that a particular situation called for such intervention. Furthermore, since the Church Manual originates from the General Conference they are the foremost experts on its content and interpretation. In short, despite Pastor DeSilva’s having been appalled at their decision, there was nothing wrong with the five leaders within the General Conference having written the letters of interpretation that they did. Finally, the 18th edition’s use of “church officers and leaders, pastors, and members” in place of the 17th edition’s “churches” makes it clear that whether or not associations like the Group had standing to make appeals to their union before, they very definitely have that right now.
To summarize, each level of organization has its own legitimate sphere of action. Within the local church the business meeting is the highest authority. So long as it is acting within its designated parameters and all concerned are satisfied that it is doing its job in the way that it ought to there is no reason for any other level of the organization to be involved with its activities. Should questions or concerns arise regarding either the processes or the decisions of the local church the questions or concerns are to be taken to the conference. The conference is to give answers to the best of its ability. Should those answers not provide sufficient illumination on the matter the question or concern is to be taken on to the union. Once a clear answer is received the church is expected to act in accordance with it.
These relationships and processes are defined by the Church Manual. As previously stated, the Church Manual is a product of the General Conference, which is the highest authority within the Seventh-day Adventist Church. It defines the relationships between all other levels of the organization and delegates to them the power that they wield, which means that the General Conference gets the final word on the interpretation and use of that delegated power.
Monday, July 12, 2010
The Epic, Pt. 70
To make this point still clearer, allow us to offer a parable before we proceed with our story. A young man had a large family with many siblings. One day he observed his eldest brother taking some pills. He investigated and discovered that they were prescription drugs that his brother had no legitimate reason to be taking. When he confronted his brother about the drug abuse the brother denied everything, claiming that he had only been taking vitamin pills. The young man took what he knew to the rest of the family to seek their help in staging an intervention with the eldest brother. The family was shocked. They went to the eldest brother and he repeated his denial and the story that the pills had merely been vitamins. The family members began taking sides. Some believed the young man, others his eldest brother. Finally, the young man’s father came to him and insisted that he sit down with his eldest brother and reach a compromise because of what the situation was doing to the rest of the family. This demand perplexed the young man. What sort of compromise could he reach with his brother about a drug habit? That his brother would only abuse pills on alternate days? That he would switch to abusing less potent pills? On the other hand, what if somehow he was wrong and his brother was only taking vitamin pills? It would be silly to demand that his brother stop taking vitamins, or even that he take fewer of them. The young man couldn’t escape his conviction that in this situation the truth had to be established and an all-or-nothing course of action taken as a result of that truth.
In the wake of the executive committee’s recommendations the Group was left with three problems. The first was that the fundamental question at the heart of our appeal had gone unanswered. The second was that, in contradiction to his earlier statements, Elder Miller was now insisting that we were not permitted to seek clarification from the union in what had turned out to be the absence of a direct answer from the conference. The third problem was that the conference’s recommendations put responsibility for answering the question in the hands of the Takoma Park Church which, given the heavy-handed way business is conducted by the pastors, effectively meant that the decision was in the hands of Pastor DeSilva. With Pastor DeSilva’s established bias on the subject, this would virtually guarantee that even if the recommendations were approved for formality’s sake that they would never actually be implemented.
To address these matters the Group took a two-pronged approach. First, Sister L communicated with a contact in the North American Division administration, seeking a second opinion on Elder Miller’s interpretation that the Manual would not allow the Group to appeal to the union. Second, Elder B made contact with Elder Ramirez to address the Group’s concerns that there would be no follow-through on Pastor DeSilva’s part regarding the recommendations. Both of these communications had interesting results.
Elder B’s communication with Elder Ramirez took place by phone. During the conversation Elder Ramirez expressed surprise that there had not been more Group members present at the ministries board meeting in which the conference had presented its recommendations. He particularly mentioned the absence of Brother G. Elder B explained that as a member of the accountability board Brother G was specifically excluded from membership on the ministries board, and that since whomever had called the meeting had closed it to all but members of the ministries board, Brother G and other leaders of the church who were not on the ministries board had been prevented from attending. (This exchange highlighted a couple of significant facts. First, there is no single administrative body in the Takoma Park Church that can be called to meet which includes all of the high-ranking elected leaders of the church. Second, in choosing to believe Pastor DeSilva’s interpretations of the workings of the church’s governance the conference found that they did not get what they expected.) On the matter of not being able to trust that Pastor DeSilva would follow through on the recommendations of the executive committee Elder Ramirez promised Elder B that a representative of the conference would attend both of the upcoming meetings at which the recommendations were due to be discussed in order to see that they were taken seriously.
On Friday evening, June 19, 2009, Elder B received another phone call from Elder Ramirez. He wanted to know whether she would be attending camp meeting the next day, and if so, whether they could meet in the afternoon. Elder B responded that she was planning to attend and would be willing to meet. During that meeting the following afternoon it came to light that in researching the question of right to appeal Sister L’s NAD contact had called Elder Miller that Friday to hear directly his views on the subject. In the course of the conversation the NAD contact had mentioned that Sister L had been providing him with regular reports about the situation in Takoma Park. While he didn’t show it in conversation with the NAD contact, Elder Miller was rather unhappy about the conversation and the information that someone in the Group had been in regular contact with NAD administration. The purpose of the meeting between Elder B and Elder Ramirez was to convey this displeasure. It was expressed that if the Group were to attempt to appeal further before the church had taken formal action on the executive committee’s recommendations and the executive committee heard about it that they would consider the Group very arrogant. There was an implication that negative consequences would result from such action. It was also implied that the communication between Sister L and her NAD contact was somehow improper and ought to be stopped by the Group. Elder B was rather taken aback by this “advice,” which was presented as being for the Group’s own good. The Group as a whole, upon hearing about it, was rather taken aback that the conference administration would have the nerve to attempt to dictate whom members of the Group could or could not speak with or that they would seek to restrict the subjects of any such conversations.
On Sunday evening, June 21, 2009, Sister L finally received a formal answer from her NAD contact on how the Church Manual’s statement about appeals ought to be interpreted. The response was that there was no consistent opinion among Church Manual experts. Some believed that a group such as the Group did have the right to appeal to a union executive committee for clarification; others so far restricted the right to appeal as to allow only conferences to do so. (This ambiguity of policy was clarified by changes made to the Church Manual that were just ratified at the GC Session in Atlanta. Our next post will speak to this matter, as well as the long-promised discussions of the powers of the various levels of the denominational hierarchy and analysis of Elder Miller’s presentation to the ministries board, which ultimately all speak to the same issues.)
Next: At the Ministries Board
Religious
Wednesday, July 7, 2010
Advice from the Spirit of Prophesy, Pt. 23
"A strange thing has come into our churches. Men who are placed in positions of responsibility that they may be wise helpers to their fellow-workers, have come to suppose that they were set as kings and rulers in the churches, to say to one brother. Do this, to another, Do that, and to another, Be sure to labor in such and such a way. There have been places where the workers have been told that if they did not follow the instruction of these men of responsibility, their pay from the conference would be withheld.
"It is right for the workers to counsel together as brethren; but that man who endeavors to lead his fellow-workers to seek his individual counsel and advice regarding the details of their work, and to learn their duty from him, is in a dangerous position, and needs to learn what responsibilities are really comprehended in his office. God has appointed no man to be conscience for his fellow-man. It is not wise to lay so much responsibility upon an officer that he will feel that he is forced to become a dictator" (Jehovah Is Our King, pp.12, 13).
"Those who are seeking to know the truth and to understand the will of God, who are faithful to the light and zealous in the performance of their daily duties, will surely know of the doctrine, for they will be guided into all truth. God does not promise, by the masterly acts of His providence, to irresistibly bring men to the knowledge of His truth, when they do not seek for truth and have no desire to know the truth. Men have the power to quench the Spirit of God; the power of choosing is left with them. They are allowed freedom of action. They may be obedient through the name and grace of our Redeemer, or they may be disobedient, and realize the consequences. Man is responsible for receiving or rejecting sacred and eternal truth. The Spirit of God is continually convicting, and souls are deciding for or against the truth. The deportment, the words, the actions, of the minister of Christ may balance a soul for or against the truth. How important that every act of the life be such that it need not be repented of. Especially is this important among the ambassadors of Christ, who are acting in the place of Christ" (Testimonies to the Church, Vol. 3, pp.427, 428).
Friday, June 18, 2010
Pause
There are a lot of things that happen in addition to the business meetings. Daily religious programs, workshops, and concerts are held. There is an exhibit hall where various Church organizations and independant ministries publicize their activities and businesses catering to the Adventist lifestyle advertise their wares. Each evening different divisions of the world church make formal reports on the evangelistic work in their areas. Attendance is estimated to be as high as 80,000 people over the course of a Session. With that many Adventists traveling to one place from around the world the event also takes on the atmosphere of a giant family reunion.
We expect that the eyes of the Adventist world will be focused on Session for its duration and we have decided not to try to compete. Therefore, this will be our last post until after Session concludes in early July. Rest assured, we will be back when Session is over.
In the meantime we invite all those who will be attending Session, or even just watching parts of it on TV, to observe how the business sessions are conducted. Particularly watch how the meeting chair conducts themselves in regard to the percentage of the meeting they spend talking and the sorts of things they do or do not say (administrative comments vs. issue-related comments). Then compare your observations to what you see in how your pastor chairs the meetings of your local church. The results may be quite interesting.
Monday, June 14, 2010
The Epic, Pt. 69
“Gentlemen,
“In regards to the Takoma Park Church issue, the Potomac Conference Executive Committee voted last night to take some actions that seek reconciliation between the two sides. However, the committee is not ready to articulate them. We will meet again in about two weeks to finalize these actions. We will officially inform you of the outcome as soon as we are ready. Thank you for your prayers and continue interest in seen this issue resolved. I wish you a blessed Sabbath.
“Jorge A. RamÃrez
“Vice President for Administration
“Potomac Conference”
On June 10, 2009 word began to circulate that the Potomac Conference leadership had called a meeting of Takoma Park’s Church Ministries Board to be held the following evening, June 11. The conference was setting the agenda which, though not announced, was assumed to pertain to Takoma Park’s governance problems. It was also announced that it was to be a closed meeting—only members of the ministries board were to be allowed in the room. The combination of the short notice and meeting closure excluded many members of the Group from attending. (Most of the Group’s inner circle held elected leadership positions, just not ones that came with a seat on the ministries board.) We were surprised and disappointed that the conference chose to so exclude those who had made the appeal from hearing their decision on the matter.
After an introduction by Pastor DeSilva the meeting was turned over to Elder Miller. He gave a brief history of the appeal process we had followed (as he saw it, anyway). He informed the ministries board that after each side had made their presentations to the executive committee the committee had come to some very general conclusions and appointed a six-person delegation of committee members plus one Church Manual expert to study the matter further and flesh out the general direction that the committee had decided on. Elder Miller stated that the Church Manual expert who had assisted them was Dr. Gary Paterson. (We later discovered that this consultation with Dr. Paterson was not quite as it was represented to the ministries board, but we’ll get to that in a later post.) Elder Miller went on to say that the executive committee had met again that afternoon in a special session to hear the report of the delegation and finalize its recommendations.
Before presenting the formal recommendations of the executive committee Elder Miller declared that the committee had concluded that there was some misunderstanding about its role and power, and went on to “clarify” the misunderstanding. He said that the executive committee’s only “engagement” with the activities of a local congregation is to advise and disband congregations. He further stated that there was a need to be cautious that the Church Manual not be violated in the process of trying to enforce the Church Manual. In this context he claimed that involving the executive committee in its advisory capacity with the business of the local church should only occur at the formal request of the whole church body. Elder Miller compared the situation to small groups requesting that items be placed on the agenda of a constituency meeting and being told that they must first have the request endorsed by a congregation. He went on to describe the “role and power” of the higher administrative levels of the Church. Elder Miller claimed that the union's only power was to provide clarification on decisions and recommendations of the conference and to disband conferences. He further claimed that the division has no power at all because it is simply an arm of the General Conference, and that the General Conference can only advise and disband unions. His conclusion to all of this was that the executive committee was making a few recommendations to the Takoma Park Church, but that the church business meeting, as the highest authority in the congregation, was within its power to refuse them.
Elder Miller also stated that once the business meeting of the church made a decision the church must “move ahead.” In this statement we saw yet another veiled jab at the Group—his assertion that small groups had no right to appeal to the executive committee having been the first one—but this statement conveniently ignored the fact that the circumstances surrounding the original approval of the change in governance did not constitute a legitimate decision by the business meeting of the church. See The Epic, Pt. 5 (posted 10-19-08) and Double Take (posted 4-5-10) for explanations of the illegitimacy of the decision.
On the subject of whether a “small group” could appeal to the executive committee, Elder Miller took this opportunity to attempt to distance himself from the statement in the Manual that if a church was dissatisfied with a decision of the conference that it could appeal to the union for clarification. On this occasion he interpreted this statement as referring to an entire congregations' dissatisfaction, not that of an unofficial group within the congregation. Under this interpretation a group like the Group would have no standing for appeal to the union unless a formal decision to appeal was voted by the congregation. In making this interpretation Elder Miller made it sound as if it had been the Group that first introduced this statement from the Manual into the equation and that we were wrong to have done so. Once again he was conveniently ignoring the historical fact that he was the one to introduce this statement and the procedure described therein in his letter to the Group on June 17, 2008. The Group’s appeal to the statement since that date had simply been an attempt to follow through with the process that Elder Miller himself had prescribed. Just to remind everyone of what was said on that occasion, here is the relevant excerpt from that letter (the full text can be found in The Epic, Pt. 25, posted 9-15-09):
“I understand that you did take a request to the board of elders, on April 23, to refer this back to the church in Business session. This was denied. The next appropriate step would have been to then contact the conference administration with your dispute, with the full knowledge of the Pastor and board of elders to contact the conference in an official capacity and request a meeting. If the decision then made would not have met your group’s approval it would then be referred to the Executive Committee. After the Executive Committee the manual states:
“‘Churches should look to the local conference for advice pertaining to the operating of the church or on questions arising from the Church Manual. If mutual understanding or agreement is not reached, the matter should be referred to the union for clarification.’ xxii Church Manual 2005 edition.
“We will be glad to work a process as understood in principle by Matthew 18 and as outlined in the Church Manual.”
After making this presentation (the substance of which we will analyze in a separate post), Elder Miller distributed printed copies of the executive committee’s formal recommendations and made comments on each one. The following is what he distributed.
“Executive Committee Approved Recommendations
“The assigned group of the Executive Committee voted to recommend:
“1. In affirmation of the Takoma Park Church:
“a. Your support of the Mission of the Seventh-day Adventist Church
“b. Your desire to impact and reach the local community for Christ
“c. Your desire for accountability to the Mission and Vision of the church.
“d. Your desire for spiritual reconciliation
“2. Recommendations:
“a. Although the Church Manual does not specify that another name is incompatible, the Church Ministries Board should be called the Church Board
“b. The Support and Accountability Board be renamed to the Support and Accountability Council and that it be Selected by the Nominating Committee and reports to the Church Board
“c. The primary role of the Church Board is to discuss and plan the evangelism outreach for the church. The newly renamed Church Board should study pp. 90-92 in the manual to make sure the Board functions as stated.
“d. That 15 key individuals from each group join together to fast and pray; to pray for reconciliation, unity, humility, and renewed energy to focus on what it is God has called the Takoma Park Church to be. This will not be a time to discuss issues.
“e. Items a, b, & c voted by the Takoma Park Church in Business Session.”
Elder Miller asserted that the Manual doesn’t provide any process for congregations to make local hires, and that he and the executive committee’s delegation of six had found no consistency in hiring practices among the congregations they had surveyed. His conclusion from this was that it was acceptable for congregations to manage local hires however they wished. Therefore, the executive committee had concluded that there was nothing wrong with the accountability board existing separately from the ministries board for the purpose of managing local personnel, but that its conclusions should be brought back to the ministries board. To clarify the fact that it did not/should not possess the power to act independently the executive committee recommended that it be called a “council” rather than a “board.”
Elder Miller reiterated that the executive committee could not legislate the recommended reconciliation, or any other part of their recommendations. It was really a point that he dwelt on with quite a bit of fervor, so much so that one really got the impression that perhaps he didn’t like the conclusions the executive committee had come to and was rather hoping that the church would reject them, but that is conjecture rather than provable fact.
During the question period Elder J asked a couple of questions significant enough to document. Fairly quickly into the question period Pastor DeSilva had asked whether the recommended changes to the accountability board were the result of the current configuration being wrong or whether the current system was fine and the changes were purely for conciliatory purposes. Elder Miller had replied that the answer was “both/and.” Pastor DeSilva had pushed the point further, leading Elder Miller to emphasize the conciliatory aspect of the recommendations. Elder J picked up on the ambiguity of this answer and asked Elder Miller flat out why the conference was recommending changes if there wasn’t actually anything wrong with the way things were. When Elder Miller hesitated in answering Elder J put an even finer point on the question, asking Elder Miller for a definitive answer on whether the new governance was in harmony with the Church Manual. Elder Miller responded that he didn’t have before him a list of the articulated responsibilities of the various entities of the new governance system, and therefore could not give a direct answer to the question. (We feel a need to point out here that in its presentation to the executive committee the Group had provided the very lists Elder Miller claimed to be ignorant of and that their deficiencies had been discussed at length in that meeting. Either he had willfully ignored that presentation, or he was in this instance telling a deliberate lie to the ministries board. As to why he would do such a thing, the only answer that makes sense to us is that the Group did indeed prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt and he therefore couldn’t say we were wrong, but he did not want to say we were right because that would have meant the undoing of his grand schemes for change, so he chose to evade the question entirely.)
The other significant question Elder J asked was whether disciplinary action could be taken against the Group if the church considered the executive committee’s recommendations, declined them, and the Group continued to appeal. Elder Miller responded that reconciliation should be the goal, but that ultimately discipline was the church's right.
When asked how the ministries board could maintain a focus on ministry if its name was changed to “church board,” Elder Miller observed that meeting discipline was needed—the board simply needed to make a commitment to focus on important things rather than unimportant ones. To this end he recommended 1) that meeting agendas be circulated in advance so that board members could get their thoughts together ahead of time and then speak to an issue only once during a meeting rather than speaking up several times in a disorganized way, 2) that ministry issues be placed on the top of the agenda rather than the bottom so that if anything was to be shorted on time it would be less significant items, and 3) that the duties, responsibilities, and relationships of the church board and all subcommittees be articulated and written down so that everyone could understand what each entity was supposed to be focusing its effort on. (This the Group actually found to be sound advice. We can’t help noticing that it is also advice that could have been given and implemented for the betterment of Takoma Park’s governance without the interference of a consultant or deviation from the stipulations of the Church Manual.)
The ministries board didn’t take any formal action on the executive committee’s recommendations during this meeting. Pastor DeSilva declared that they would be discussed briefly at the regular ministries board meeting in July, which would then make a recommendation about them to the business meeting that was scheduled for the following week in July.
Next: Call the Question
Religious
Friday, June 11, 2010
Bullseye: Retrospective
What, then, is his basis? Borden has essentially “Christianized” secular business philosophies. In the world of secular business, everything done by the firm as a corporate body or by the individual employee is to benefit the firm. Yes, the firm exists to provide some sort of product or service to a client base, but doing that and doing it well is simply the means to the end of making the firm profit and grow. In this pursuit of benefit to the firm its employees are not only negotiable, but expendable. If someone is underperforming or insufficiently skilled they get replaced by someone better, quicker, or more highly educated. Everything is driven by the needs of the firm, and if the market changes the firm changes to find new ways of meeting its needs. These goals and methods of reaching them are periodically reexamined, and if necessary redefined, by management. Sound familiar?
The problem with transposing secular business philosophy into a religious context is that there are two key differences between the secular and religious contexts that make the secular philosophies incompatible with the religious context. The first key difference is that the secular business context is all about the corporate entity. Borden tries to make the argument that the same is true in the religious context, but as we saw in Unit of Mission the religious context is all about the individual. Therefore, the secular approach of individual expendability is incompatible. The second key difference is that in the secular business context the mission and vision of the entity are created by the entity’s leadership and are subject to change at any time. In the religious context the mission and vision have been created by God and are nonnegotiable.
“Every word of God is flawless;
he is a shield to those who take refuge in him.
“Do not add to his words,
or he will rebuke you and prove you a liar” (Proverbs 30:5, 6).
“I warn everyone who hears the words of the prophecy of this book: If anyone adds anything to them, God will add to him the plagues described in this book. And if anyone takes words away from this book of prophecy, God will take away from him his share in the tree of life and in the holy city, which are described in this book” (Revelation 22:18, 19).
So why would Christians be interested in unbiblical philosophies? To start with, not everything Borden says is bad. As described at the beginning of this series, even we were able to find some Things We Agree On. Ultimately, however, this mixture of truth and error just makes the whole thing that much more problematic, because people are lured in by the good and assume that if some of it is good it must all be good (see Advice from the Spirit of Prophesy, Pt. 19). The other lure we see is that these philosophies are trendy. It’s not a good excuse, but it is a common one. It is also a very old one. It takes very little imagination to hear all the arguments made in favor of adopting Paul Borden’s philosophies coming out of the mouths of the Israelites when they wanted a king, “The old ways were fine back in the days of Joshua, but we need to update. We need to be culturally relevant. If we had a king the unchurched people around us could relate to us better. The whole theocracy thing is really just a guideline, anyway. It’s OK if we adapt it to our local needs.” As we saw in Corporate Distinctiveness, God takes a rather dim view of such arguments.
We have often heard the critique that we are putting too much emphasis on the law, and ought to be practicing Christian love instead. But here’s the thing: the two are not mutually exclusive. Loving people doesn’t mean ignoring transgressions of God’s law. In fact, helping people to see and correct their errors is actually the most loving thing you can do for them because God does actually deal in absolutes. He saves us by grace through His substitutionary sacrifice, but that doesn’t annul His law, it is a fulfillment of that law. True acceptance of God’s sacrifice means turning away from sin and God does not excuse willful ignorance or disobedience of His law by those who claim to be His followers.
“Live as free men, but do not use your freedom as a cover-up for evil; live as servants of God” (1 Peter 2:16).
God fully expects us (with His help) to live up to the laws, regulations, and standards He gives us. This includes everything in the Bible. As Seventh-day Adventists, we also believe that that includes everything laid out in the Spirit of Prophesy (unless it can be shown to conflict with the Bible). This encompasses the structure of the Seventh-day Adventist Church, which was instituted during the lifetime of Ellen White and with her approval under the guidance of the Holy Spirit. Unfortunately, there are some who simply do not want to follow the rules, no matter how clearly they are laid out as being of divine origin and backing. Of such people God says, “Were I to write for him my laws by ten thousands, they would be regarded as a strange thing” (Hosea 8:12).
“The Lord has His appointed agencies; and if these are not discerned and respected by those who are connected with His work, if men feel free to disregard God's requirements, they must not be kept in positions of trust. They would not listen to counsel, nor to the commands of God through His appointed agencies. Like Saul, they would rush into a work that was never appointed them, and the mistakes they would make in following their human judgment would place the Israel of God where their Leader could not reveal Himself to them. Sacred things would become mingled with the common” (Youth’s Instructor, Nov. 17, 1898).
We write knowing full well that some of the minds reading this have already been closed on this subject. To those that have not we plead: let’s not abandon the expressed will of God in favor of unbiblical philosophies such as Paul Borden’s.
“Do not rebuke a mocker or he will hate you;
rebuke a wise man and he will love you” (Proverbs 9:8).
Monday, June 7, 2010
Bullseye: What the Potomac Conference Ignored
“The family concept promotes the idea of clerical tenure. Pastors assume that if they have been loyal and faithful soldiers that such behavior over a long time both protects them, in terms of their positions, and gives them authority to speak to any crucial issue facing the judicatory. The controlling principle is not effectiveness in ministry, but tenure in the family” (p.25).
“A basic value that most held was that if a pastor was perceived as a 'loyal soldier' that pastor would always be helped by the region to find a new pastorate when she or he felt that one’s ministry was over with the current congregation. This help would be forthcoming whether the current congregation was healthy and growing or dysfunctional and dying” (p.48).
This sense of tenure and entitlement has nothing to do with the concept of the church as a family, but it is a problem to have ineffective pastors being endlessly shifted from one congregation to another in order to avoid having to face up to their ineffectiveness.
“Another implication of fulfilling our mission is that we are willing to confront pastors who are ineffective” (p.32).
“In our congregational consultations our goal was to establish the pastor as the leader of the congregation. At the same time the pastor had to be willing to be held accountable for specific missional goals. If the goals were met the pastor was given even more freedom to lead. If the goals were not met, then the pastor needed to realize that perhaps a different calling and vocation was in the pastor’s future” (p.97).
“Sometimes protecting congregational leaders meant meeting with pastors to remind them that, since they now had both the authority and responsibility for ministry, if goals were not met they were accountable and could not shift the blame to others” (p.98).
“We have now learned to set goals for the pastor to achieve in the next six months to a year with the understanding that if most of the goals are not achieved the pastor needs to consider leaving that congregation. I have found that by being clear up front, it is easier to discuss the future with the pastor if things do not go well” (p.111).
Here we arrive at the solution to the problem identified in the previous set of quotes. When a pastor has proven time after time that they are incapable of effectiveness in ministry it is time for a dismissal, not another relocation. And making excuses that attempt to shift blame should not be tolerated.
“This implementation piece is crucial in producing change. I believe all the other training we did would not have amounted to much if we had not held pastors accountable for actual changes through our cluster system” (p.51).
Borden also describes that after doing a congregational consultation one member of the consulting team would meet monthly with the church’s board to see that there was follow-through and provide guidance when issues came up. Making such an effort is the only way to get a true picture of the results of such a consultation, yet this has not been part of the Potomac Conference’s system.
"Conflict mediation assumes that the fighting parties will come to the process with some degree of integrity. In dysfunctional congregations the lack of spirituality inhibits people from possessing such integrity, plus the mediators are seeking resolution in what is already a dysfunctional situation. When the real issue of conflict is the control of the congregation (this issue is never the stated issue), those with the control will never give it up unless forced to do so. The nature and purpose of conflict mediation is to get believers to be reconciled, not deal with the control issues that cause congregations to remain dysfunctional" (p.72).
While in this context Borden is assuming that it is lay leaders who are coming to the table disingenuously and in an attempt to retain power and control, he paints a realistic picture of what is actually a two-way street. Pastors trying to hang on to their congregation and their status are every bit as likely (or even more likely) to play dirty in an attempt to retain or enhance their control during a transitional period as any lay member. This is why the Potomac Conference’s policy of treating concerns about changes in governance as interpersonal disputes to be reconciled is completely useless. Not only does this approach fail to consider any underlying nuances to the situation, it deliberately ignores the directly identified issue.
“We often protected the risk takers by informing the critics that these congregations and leaders were simply doing what we had encouraged” (p.99).
“The role of judicatory leaders, particularly if they are leading that change, is to protect those taking the risks” (p.100).
Once again, we do not agree with Borden’s theories of “protection,” but we do believe that if the conference is going to initiate a program they should own up to having done so and take responsibility for the outcomes.
“Large, healthy congregational thinking means that one leads by attraction, not compulsion” (p.63).
The reference to Borden’s pet theory that only large congregations have healthy ways of doing things notwithstanding, the Potomac Conference would do well to note that compulsion is never an effective way of convincing anyone to do anything.
Wednesday, June 2, 2010
Bullseye: The Function of a Church Leader
“The cluster was to be viewed as an opportunistic platform to be used to earn the right to lead congregations through change” (p.47).
Borden’s theories of leadership involve pitting pastors against each other in competition for the attention of the regional leadership. Only those who embrace his philosophies and techniques and actively promote them in their congregations are deemed worthy of attention and assistance. Those who don’t get with the program are ignored.
“The second foundational principle is that leaders must be given the freedom to lead. God expects those who are given gifts, talents, skills, and a call to lead with excellence. This means that leaders must be given broad authority to take strong leadership roles over areas for which they are responsible. Those same leaders should also expect to provide specific, measurable, behavioral, and tangible goals relating to outcomes and then be held accountable for those goals. However, in the pursuit of these goals leaders should be given wide latitude, flexibility, and protection by those to whom the leader is accountable. Leaders also need the freedom to fail so they will be willing to risk. Obviously, too much failure indicates a lack of wisdom and leadership. On the other hand, without risk and failure the organization is doomed to eventual decline and death” (p.127).
Here we see a couple themes we have already addressed. The notions of power being concentrated in the hands of a single leader rather than a group and “protecting” pastors from differing opinions are both making encore appearances, and are still thoroughly invalid. Although Borden claims these beliefs about leadership are intended by God, he fails to cite a single biblical reference in support of this position. He mentions five Scripture references in the entire book (Ephesians 4:10-16, John 15, Isaiah 49:6, Romans 10:18-21, Revelation 1:12-16), but doesn’t actually quote any of them, and none of them support these positions on leadership. We bring all this up because, as unfounded as these positions are, Borden builds on them to support other positions regarding the role and function of pastors.
“At the beginning of an intervention our job was to create legitimate emotional imbalance among the pastors, leaders, and congregations within the region, both about the congregations and the region itself. We wanted people to say, ‘Enough is enough we will no longer tolerate the condition in which we find ourselves.’ However, once people reach that state, the next issue relates to what will be done to move from where they are to a preferable future. This is why with anecdote we always communicate the vision as the antidote to the status quo” (pp.68, 69).
“The first is that the leader must communicate the vision often, at the risk of redundancy. Second, the vision must not be presented as an option to the status quo. The status quo must be presented as unacceptable, with the vision an excellent option for a better and more effective way of living. Finally, the leader must believe enough in God and God’s people to assume that the vision can be accomplished” (p.67).
“A second strategy in leading through vision is painting the status quo as unacceptable rather than as an alternate to the vision. A good leader recognizes that she or he must help the group see that the current situation is untenable. If the group does nothing about its current situation it will get worse” (p.68).
Another brick goes up in the wall. Because (in Borden’s mind) broad power invested in the pastor cannot be challenged, the congregation is left with two options, 1) embrace the vision presented by the pastor or 2) maintain the status quo. This is really only one option because, according to the unchallengeable word of the pastor, the status quo is “unacceptable” and “untenable.”
“I see my primary task as Executive Minister to be the keeper and caster of the vision and mission” (p.67).
“Visionary leaders must stay in touch with key people and pastors, but they cannot function as chaplains, problem solvers, or managers dealing with the day to day issues of regional life” (p.67).
“As a result lay leaders realized that the pastor’s job is not to manage congregational ministries but lead them” (p.108).
Here we reach the climax of Borden’s philosophy on leadership. Not only is the pastor invested with broad, unchallengeable power to lay out to the congregation the way it must go, he is also designated as the originator, decider, and interpreter of what that way is. As such he is above dealing with “day to day issues” and has only to “stay in touch with key people” to ensure that they are indeed carrying out his will for the church. Notice that we refer to “his will” rather than “God’s will,” as we have yet to see any evidence that God is in any way involved in this.
Let’s review. First, the pastor creates (or “casts”) the vision. Second, he decides how that vision translates into measurable goals. Third, he is given broad authority to pursue those goals by whatever means he chooses, without anyone being permitted to second-guess either the goals or the strategies. Third, the pastor is not required to engage in any day to day ministry, only to keep in contact with those who are doing the work for him. Finally, at the end of a predetermined period of time a small group of people is supposed to determine whether he accomplished what he said he would—but, as we have already discussed, this aspect of the system is incompatible with Adventist congregations. The bottom line is that any pastor (particularly an Adventist pastor) who undertook to function under this system could justly be called a dictator, and a lazy one at that.
But there is a still bigger issue here. Never, never, never does God instruct individuals to submit their understanding of His will for them to the judgment or interpretation of anyone else. God doesn’t give exclusive knowledge of His will to pastors or other church leaders. Every single member is expected to seek and find God’s will for themselves. The only true role of the pastor in this regard is to urge all members to be diligent in their seeking for understanding.
“All must see and understand their duty for themselves, after seeking wisdom from God. He is the only one to whom you may commit your soul for safe-keeping. If you come to Him in faith, he will speak His mysteries to you personally. You may sit together in heavenly places with Christ. We may individually understand God's will; we may know for ourselves what He would have us do; for He will direct us if we will consent to be consecrated and humble in heart before him. Our hearts will oft burn within us as One draws nigh to commune with us as He did with Enoch. ‘Who is this that darkeneth counsel by words without knowledge.’ We need Him who is the true light that lighteth every man that cometh into the world” (Manuscript Releases, Vol. 6, p.381).
“In these last days ministers need to guard the churches against the dangers arising from the acceptance of fanciful and erroneous theories by preaching the plain truths of the Word regarding individual duty and responsibility. The people of God are to be educated to hate and forsake all unrighteousness if they would be prepared for a place in the kingdom of heaven. Teach that the fruits of repentance are to be seen in the life in deeds of righteousness. By lives of faith and devotion, and reliance upon the Word of God as the foundation of all faith, by acts of unselfishness and sincerity, teach them to make known the saving grace of Christ” (Review and Herald, February 18, 1909 par. 1).
So what does the Bible have to say about the duties of church leaders?
“You must teach what is in accord with sound doctrine. Teach the older men to be temperate, worthy of respect, self-controlled, and sound in faith, in love and in endurance.
“Likewise, teach the older women to be reverent in the way they live, not to be slanderers or addicted to much wine, but to teach what is good. Then they can train the younger women to love their husbands and children, to be self-controlled and pure, to be busy at home, to be kind, and to be subject to their husbands, so that no one will malign the word of God.
“Similarly, encourage the young men to be self-controlled. In everything set them an example by doing what is good. In your teaching show integrity, seriousness and soundness of speech that cannot be condemned, so that those who oppose you may be ashamed because they have nothing bad to say about us.
“Teach slaves to be subject to their masters in everything, to try to please them, not to talk back to them, and not to steal from them, but to show that they can be fully trusted, so that in every way they will make the teaching about God our Savior attractive.
“For the grace of God that brings salvation has appeared to all men. It teaches us to say 'No' to ungodliness and worldly passions, and to live self-controlled, upright and godly lives in this present age, while we wait for the blessed hope—the glorious appearing of our great God and Savior, Jesus Christ, who gave himself for us to redeem us from all wickedness and to purify for himself a people that are his very own, eager to do what is good.
“These, then, are the things you should teach. Encourage and rebuke with all authority. Do not let anyone despise you” (Titus 2).
The list we derive is profound in its simplicity: 1) teach sound doctrine and upright living, 2) encourage, and 3) rebuke. Nowhere in this list (or any other to be found in the Bible) is any item pertaining to the wielding of power. This is because it is not a duty of the pastor to hold or exercise any power beyond the forcefulness of the proven Word of God which he is to deliver faithfully and in abundance to the congregation and the community. And the need for this work of teaching sound doctrine is not to be underestimated.
“The fact that there is no controversy or agitation among God's people, should not be regarded as conclusive evidence that they are holding fast to sound doctrine. There is reason to fear that they may not be clearly discriminating between truth and error. When no new questions are started by investigation of the Scriptures, when no difference of opinion arises which will set men to searching the Bible for themselves, to make sure that they have the truth, there will be many now, as in ancient times, who will hold to tradition, and worship they know not what.
“I have been shown that many who profess to have a knowledge of present truth, know not what they believe. They do not understand the evidences of their faith. They have no just appreciation of the work for the present time. When the time of trial shall come, there are men now preaching to others, who will find, upon examining the positions they hold, that there are many things for which they can give no satisfactory reason. Until thus tested, they knew not their great ignorance.
“And there are many in the church who take it for granted that they understand what they believe, but, until controversy arises, they do not know their own weakness. When separated from those of like faith, and compelled to stand singly and alone to explain their belief, they will be surprised to see how confused are their ideas of what they had accepted as truth. Certain it is that there has been among us a departure from the living God, and a turning to men, putting human wisdom in place of divine” (Gospel Workers, pp. 298, 299).
The encouragement aspect of these duties is quite straightforward.
“For I was hungry and you gave me something to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you invited me in, I needed clothes and you clothed me, I was sick and you looked after me, I was in prison and you came to visit me” (Matthew 25:35, 36).
The rebuking, on the other hand, needs a somewhat more detailed examination.
“Jesus said to his disciples: ‘Things that cause people to sin are bound to come, but woe to that person through whom they come. It would be better for him to be thrown into the sea with a millstone tied around his neck than for him to cause one of these little ones to sin. So watch yourselves.
“‘If your brother sins, rebuke him, and if he repents, forgive him. If he sins against you seven times in a day, and seven times comes back to you and says, 'I repent,' forgive him’" (Luke 17:1-4).
“Those who sin are to be rebuked publicly, so that the others may take warning.
“I charge you, in the sight of God and Christ Jesus and the elect angels, to keep these instructions without partiality, and to do nothing out of favoritism.
“Do not be hasty in the laying on of hands, and do not share in the sins of others. Keep yourself pure” (1 Timothy 5:20-22).
“Those whom I love I rebuke and discipline. So be earnest, and repent” (Revelation 3:19).
“There will ever be a spirit to rise up against the reproof of sins and wrongs. But the voice of reproof should not be hushed because of this. Those whom God has set apart as ministers of righteousness have solemn responsibilities laid upon them to reprove the sins of the people. Paul commanded Titus, ‘These things speak, and exhort, and rebuke with all authority. Let no man despise thee.’ There are ever those who will despise the one who dares to reprove sin. But when required, reproof must be given. Paul directs Titus to rebuke a certain class sharply, that they may be sound in the faith. And how shall the reproof be given? Let the apostle answer: ‘With all long-suffering and doctrine.’ The one at fault must be shown that his course is not in harmony with the Word of God. But never should the wrongs of God's people be passed by indifferently. Those who faithfully discharge their unpleasant duties under a sense of their accountability to God, will receive his blessing” (Signs of the Times, Sept. 16, 1880).
“To exalt a minister as perfection because he has not displeased any one by reproving errors, not only brings a snare upon the minister, but brings disaster upon the people. He who does not hurt the spiritual self-complacency of the people is almost deified by them, while a devoted, faithful servant of God, who lays bare the errors of the church-members, is supposed to be defective, because he does not see what they suppose are their personal merits. He reproves wrongs which really exist, and this is counted an indignity, and his authority and instruction are cast aside and trodden under foot of men. These extremes in the way the people look upon ministers are found among the professed children of God; and who will now examine their hearts, and tenderly, earnestly and faithfully set these things in order?” (Review and Herald, July 25, 1893).
What more can we say? Once again we see a stark contrast between the philosophies of Paul Borden and the requirements of Scripture.
Friday, May 28, 2010
Bullseye: The Current State of Leadership
As previously discussed, the Bible and Spirit of Prophesy do not endorse many if not most of the “tough acts of leadership” that Borden advocates, but in a larger sense he has a point. In a religious context particularly, there is the tendency to slip into the comfortable belief that all must be happiness and warm-fuzziness, and that anything which isn’t should not be part of the religious experience. All professions have their share of unpleasant but proper and necessary tasks, and the professional is remiss if they ignore these responsibilities simply because they are unpleasant. (We are going to leave this subject dangling for the moment because we are devoting this post to a description of the current state of leadership in the church. Our next post will consider the responsibilities and privileges of church leaders.)
“Most had never led a congregation to growth and health (this was one reason they were in judicatory or denominational work) and they were ignorant of most of the voices who are writing about congregational health, congregational growth, changing organizations, or missional thinking” (p.41).
“Along with other consultants I was confrontational with pastors and congregational leaders about Jesus’ mandate to go and make disciples. I pointed out that this was not happening in our congregations and as a result we were being disobedient and failing to meet the very purpose for the church’s existence. I then tried to show the values, and in turn behaviors, that had led to this predicament. Through the consultation process we then offered a better way of acting which would demand a change in values for the congregation” (p.72).
As much as we would like to, we can’t dispute that the Adventist Church often participates in the practice of dealing with ineffective ministers by “kicking them upstairs.” This brings us back to a couple of subjects we have already covered, specifically that 1) being a pastor is as much a profession as any other career and if the pastor isn’t being effective in their job they should not be allowed to continue to hold it, and 2) in religious contexts there is a tendency to shy away from unpleasant but proper and necessary tasks. We could also argue that this touches on the “protection” mentality among clergy, but in any case the end result is a tolerance of mediocrity in job performance which should not exist.
The other issue raised by these statements is that of what pastors are doing with their time (and what they should be doing, but again we are straying into the material of another post). Borden identifies two things that pastors are not doing, 1) studying what others have to say about congregational health and growth, changing organizations, and missional thinking, and 2) following the Great Commission. As we stated in the original post of this series, the need to get serious about the Great Commission is one of the things about which we agree with Borden. We also find it oddly appropriate to define the activities of our pastoral leadership in terms of what they are not doing since in too many cases one can find little evidence of activity beyond weekly occupation of the pulpit. (Don’t get us wrong, preparing and delivering sermons is an important part of the pastor’s job, but it’s not the entire job.) We are less sympathetic with Borden’s complaint that pastors aren’t keeping up with the trendy thinking on organizational philosophy. “There is need of systematic labor; but where some of you are so long in devising, and planning, and getting ready for the work, Satan preoccupies the field with bewitching fables, and the attention of men becomes absorbed in the delusions of the master deceiver” (Review and Herald, March 13, 1888). In other words, spend less time worrying about how others think you should do your job, and more time actually doing it, because if you wait until you are thoroughly versed in the latest popular theory you will never get around to doing anything.
“The elder ministers should be qualified to so educate the younger men that they may become able ministers, who will feel the responsibility of the work, and will build upon the sure foundation. There are many who neglect their duties outside the desk, and the condition of the churches testifies to the character of their work. Doubts, unbelief, backsliding, formality, exist in a marked degree. Oh! how much men of God are needed, who will faithfully warn the people of their sins. …Talents are now buried in earthly, temporal pursuits, that should be used in saving souls from perdition. When the church stand as God's chosen people should, they will be a peculiar people, zealous of good works. There will be no slackness, no concord with Belial. Oh that we could realize what God's people might now be, had they kept themselves in his love, without any compromise with evil, and had retained the peculiar character that distinguished them, and separated them from the world! In experience, in wisdom, in true holiness, they would be years in advance of what they now are. But as a people our obedience, our devotion, our spiritual attainments, are very far from being in proportion to our privileges, and to our sacred obligation to walk as children of the light” (Review and Herald, October 21, 1884 par. 22).
Borden blames the majority of the evils he sees in the current state of church leadership on the fact that congregations and denominational hierarchies focus governing power in committees or boards. As we have already discussed, the solution he advocates for this perceived problem is to eliminate committees and boards and give all that power to individuals, specifically pastors.
“In most religious settings we find it almost impossible to confront an individual in order to tell that person he or she is performing poorly in conducting ministry. It is even more difficult to confront a group and inform the people in the group that they have failed to conduct ministry well” (p.128).
“The marriage of authority, responsibility, and accountability is best done with individuals, not groups. First, give an individual the authority and responsibility for a task. Then establish how this individual will be held accountable for results. Then let that individual select whomever she or he desires to help them. This person, however, clearly understands that he or she will be held accountable, not the people selected to minister with them” (p.128).
This system may be, as Borden describes it, “efficient,” but it fails to take into account the fallibility of humans. The best, most efficient system of government on earth is a benevolent monarchy. The problem is that there is no way of ensuring the “benevolent” part. Likewise, the government of heaven will likely resemble the philosophies of communism, but communism on earth is a dismal failure because it depends on the goodness of people. On the other hand, capitalism and democracy assume and encourage the opportunistic aspects of human nature, but they also provide checks and balances to counteract that behavior when it becomes harmful, which is why they work so well in this fallen world. Since we are still in this fallen world, we need to place power where it is the safest—under the guardianship of the collective wisdom.
“When this power which God has placed in the church is accredited to one man, and he is invested with the authority to be judgment for other minds, then the true Bible order is changed. Satan's efforts upon such a man's mind will be most subtle and sometimes overpowering, because through this mind he thinks he can affect many others. Your position on leadership is correct, if you give to the highest organized authority in the church what you have given to one man. God never designed that His work should bear the stamp of one man's mind and one man's judgment” (Testimonies to the Church, Vol. 3, p. 493).
“There is much for men in responsible positions to learn. When men feel that their ideas are without a flaw, it is time for them to change their position from president to that of a learner. When they think that their ideas, their judgment, should be accepted without question, they show that they are unfit for their position. God sees not as man sees. Whatever position a man may be called to fill, his judgment is not to be regarded as unerring. His entrusted responsibility makes it far more needful than it otherwise would be for him to be free from all egotism, and willing to receive counsel” (Manuscript 55, June 3, 1897, "Development of Workers").
We included the following statement earlier in this series, but it is equally applicable to this subject and bears repeating.
“Notwithstanding the fact that Paul was personally taught by God, he had no strained ideas of individual responsibility. While looking to God for direct guidance, he was ever ready to recognize the authority vested in the body of believers united in church fellowship. He felt the need of counsel, and when matters of importance arose, he was glad to lay these before the church and to unite with his brethren in seeking God for wisdom to make right decisions. Even ‘the spirits of the prophets,’ he declared, ‘are subject to the prophets. For God is not the author of confusion, but of peace, as in all churches of the saints.’ 1 Corinthians 14:32, 33. With Peter, he taught that all united in church capacity should be ‘subject one to another.’ 1 Peter 5:5” (Acts of the Apostles, p.200).
Monday, May 24, 2010
Bullseye: Leadership Criteria
What criteria must a person meet in order to be a leader in God’s church?
“Leadership in one sense is amoral. It can be use to lead people to great achievements, such as those who led thirteen colonies to independence and nationhood. It can also be used to produce great evil, such as Adolph Hitler” (p.57).*
Borden makes this statement but then fails to thoroughly consider its ramifications in the criteria he sets out for church leaders. Because skill in leadership can be used for productive or destructive ends it is essential in choosing leaders for the church to consider their history and the moral standards they have given evidence of adhering to. Borden doesn’t do that. He looks exclusively at whether or not the potential leader is capable of producing the end result he desires, and he doesn’t care how they achieve that result. Basically, Borden believes that ends justify means.
“We also defined leaders as people who actually had other people following them. Leadership ceased to be a position and became a function” (p.38).
“We insisted that leadership has one basic criterion, and that is whether anyone is really following or not” (p.107).
“Good leaders produce effective ministry and lead healthy congregations. Poor leaders are not only ineffective, they assist congregations in creating even greater dysfunction” (p.106).
Even when Borden enlarges on his basic criterion the additional requirements he lists do not take into account any moral, spiritual, or theological aspects.
“After all it is not enough to find good leaders, but we mujst find leaders who have the courage to perform, the wisdom to know what foundational principles need to be adopted, and the insight to implement effective strategies” (p.58).
“Moving from dysfunction to health demands courage, passion, and the willingness to risk, coupled with the understanding of the basic principles required for change and how to lead change. It also requires the wisdom to implement these principles with both skill and courage. Too often I believe we have asked people who are not leaders, or have not been trained to be leaders, to lead such dangerous change” (p.108).
The Bible’s criteria for church leaders are very different.
“Here is a trustworthy saying: If anyone sets his heart on being an overseer, he desires a noble task. Now the overseer must be above reproach, the husband of but one wife, temperate, self-controlled, respectable, hospitable, able to teach, not given to drunkenness, not violent but gentle, not quarrelsome, not a lover of money. He must manage his own family well and see that his children obey him with proper respect. (If anyone does not know how to manage his own family, how can he take care of God's church?) He must not be a recent convert, or he may become conceited and fall under the same judgment as the devil. He must also have a good reputation with outsiders, so that he will not fall into disgrace and into the devil's trap.
“Deacons, likewise, are to be men worthy of respect, sincere, not indulging in much wine, and not pursuing dishonest gain. They must keep hold of the deep truths of the faith with a clear conscience. They must first be tested; and then if there is nothing against them, let them serve as deacons.
“In the same way, their wives are to be women worthy of respect, not malicious talkers but temperate and trustworthy in everything.
“A deacon must be the husband of but one wife and must manage his children and his household well. Those who have served well gain an excellent standing and great assurance in their faith in Christ Jesus.
“Although I hope to come to you soon, I am writing you these instructions so that, if I am delayed, you will know how people ought to conduct themselves in God's household, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and foundation of the truth” (1 Timothy 3:1-15).
“The reason I left you in Crete was that you might straighten out what was left unfinished and appoint elders in every town, as I directed you. An elder must be blameless, the husband of but one wife, a man whose children believe and are not open to the charge of being wild and disobedient. Since an overseer is entrusted with God's work, he must be blameless—not overbearing, not quick-tempered, not given to drunkenness, not violent, not pursuing dishonest gain. Rather he must be hospitable, one who loves what is good, who is self-controlled, upright, holy and disciplined. He must hold firmly to the trustworthy message as it has been taught, so that he can encourage others by sound doctrine and refute those who oppose it” (Titus 1:5-9).
Let’s review that list of biblical criteria. To be a leader in the church one must be:
above reproach
monogamous
temperate
self-controlled
respectable
hospitable
able to teach
not given to drunkenness
not violent, but gentle
not quarrelsome
not a lover of money
a good manager of their own family
not a recent convert
of good reputation among nonbelievers
worthy of respect
sincere
not pursuing dishonest gain
holding the deep truths of the faith
not malicious talkers
trustworthy
not overbearing
holy
capable of refuting false doctrine
We see a cavernous difference between the biblical criteria and the criteria of Paul Borden. The biblical requirements are, admittedly, a tall order, but they revolve around three simple principles. First, a church leader is to exemplify all virtues to the greatest extent humanly possible so that the cause of God is not besmirched by their behavior and others can learn from their example. Second, the church of God is intended to function as a family, therefore individuals who have proven that they manage their families well may be assumed to have the skills necessary to manage the church well. Finally, the church leader must be thoroughly versed on the beliefs of the church so they can teach them to others and refute erroneous beliefs.
“May the Lord impress upon the minds and hearts of all connected with the sacred work of God the importance of ascertaining whether those who are to minister as deacons and elders are suitable men to be entrusted with the flock of God. Jesus calls Himself the ‘Good Shepherd.’ He does this in contrast with those who occupy positions of trust in connection with the church, but who have no right to these places, because they put a wrong mold upon the work. What is natural will appear. Compare the Good Shepherd, who gave His life for His sheep, with those who are filled with self-esteem, puffed up, dictatorial, loving to rule in the church.
“The prophets have specified Christ's attributes. They foretold Him as a gentle Shepherd, who would carry the lambs in His bosom. There are others pointed out by prophecy, who have accepted the position of leaders and religious instructors, whom the Word of God rebukes for their neglect, in their ignorance, to do the work which they should have been doing in their places of responsibility” (Manuscript Releases, Vol. 21, p.3).
One quick detail we should address here is who we are talking about when we speak of church leaders. As we have pointed out in posts prior to this series (see The Lord’s Anointed, Pt. 2), in the biblical model of church leadership there was no such thing as clergy. All administration of local congregations was done by what we would now call lay leaders. Borden, on the other hand, mentions lay leaders in passing from time to time during his discussions on criteria for leaders but focuses his primary energy on pastors. He clearly considers pastoral leadership superior to lay leadership. So long as that is to be his approach we submit that the degree of superiority he implies should also be found in the extent to which they meet the biblical criteria for lay leaders of the church.
*Two of the quotes from Hit the Bullseye that are featured in this post contain spelling or grammar errors. We aren’t having a bad typing day; we are reproducing them exactly as they appear in the book.